Everyday thousands of children are being sexually abused. You can stop the abuse of at least one child by simply praying. You can possibly stop the abuse of thousands of children by forwarding the link in First Time Visitor? by email, Twitter or Facebook to every Christian you know. Save a child or lots of children!!!! Do Something, please!

3:15 PM prayer in brief:
Pray for God to stop 1 child from being molested today.
Pray for God to stop 1 child molestation happening now.
Pray for God to rescue 1 child from sexual slavery.
Pray for God to save 1 girl from genital circumcision.
Pray for God to stop 1 girl from becoming a child-bride.
If you have the faith pray for 100 children rather than one.
Give Thanks. There is more to this prayer here

Please note: All my writings and comments appear in bold italics in this colour

Showing posts with label Hillsong. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Hillsong. Show all posts

Friday, 22 May 2026

Wolves Among the Sheep > Brian Houston - The troubled super pastor

 

Brian Houston says his X account was 'compromised': ‘I do not watch pornography’

Days after an explicit pornographic video appeared on his X account, Hillsong Church founder Brian Houston assured supporters that he doesn't watch pornography and alleged that someone with access to one of his devices compromised the account.

“I wanted to take a moment to speak to people personally and address a vile post that appeared on my X account a few days ago. A good starting point is to say, I do not watch pornography, not online, not on social media, nowhere else,” the founder of the Australia-based global megachurch declared in a video on Facebook Wednesday.

“I've been in active ministry for over 54 years, and in that time, I've seen the fallout of pornography on individuals, on marriages, on families, and I detest it.”

The 72-year-old Houston said at the time the post appeared on his X page that he and his wife, Bobbie, were “in bed.”

Taking issue with The Christian Post’s use of the word "hacked" in last week's report, Houston clarified that he never used the word hacked and instead said "compromised," adding that there is a difference between an account being hacked and compromised. 

“According to The Christian Post, and probably others, they said, and a tweet that I did since then, that I said that I was hacked. I never used the word hacked. That's false. It's untrue. I did say my account was compromised, and you might say, 'Well, what's the difference?' But I think that there's a difference,” he explained.

“I don't believe that it's likely that anyone actually hacked into my X account. Not impossible, but not likely. I think there's a different explanation. I believe that someone has used one of my own devices, using my own passcode, to access my phone without my knowledge or my permission.

"Someone with a grudge wanted to cause maximum damage, but perhaps minimum effort, to smear me and to humiliate me. And I don't think it's the first time it's happened.” 

Houston, who, after leaving Hillsong, launched the ministry Jesusfollowers.tv with his wife, said in an X post last week: “This account was compromised overnight. Any odd posts, links, or messages shared earlier were not legitimate and have been reported and deleted. Thank you for your patience.” 

The pastor further clarified that he didn’t believe this was the first time the unknown person had gained access to his accounts and said he and his wife were offended by the post.

“If you were exposed to that video, and you were disgusted or offended, I totally understand. Bobbie and I feel exactly the same way,” he said before asking for prayers.

“Bobbie and I are not quitters. We keep trucking on. I'm asking you to pray for us, and we will certainly continue to pray for all the people in our world. God bless you,” he ended.

In a separate incident in 2024, Houston said his X account was hacked after the account tweeted the words “ladies and girls kissing,” drawing scrutiny from social media users. 

Houston later reposted a statement shared by one of his assistants urging users to disregard any recent posts that “seem out of the normal.”

“Rest assured we are working on discovering how Ps. Brian was hacked,” the statement read at the time. “Our team has ascertained that someone logged into his account from a location within the USA. We’ve changed his password so here’s hoping they no longer have access. Please disregard anything that seems out of the normal. For your safety remember Pastor Brian does not contact anyone privately.”

In January 2022, Hillsong Church announced that Houston was stepping down from his role at the church's helm.

Houston resigned as Hillsong Church’s global senior pastor in March 2022, amid revelations that two women made allegations of sexual misconduct against him. 

Before his formal resignation from Hillsong Church, Houston initially stepped down from Hillsong's boards in September 2021 as he faced criminal charges related to allegations he concealed sex abuse committed by his father, Frank Houston, decades earlier after he heard about it in 1999. Houston denied any wrongdoing, and an Australian court later found him not guilty of the charges.

Four months before the acquittal, Houston pled guilty to driving under the influence of alcohol and driving with a blood alcohol content of .08% or more in California. He was also sentenced to three years' probation, a $140 fine, and other penalties.

Court records show that after an arrest on Feb. 26, 2022, Houston pled "not guilty" to driving under the influence of alcohol, driving with a blood alcohol content of .08% or more, and failing to display two license plates on the vehicle he was driving.

The Hillsong Church founder, who was set for a pre-trial hearing that June, reversed course on the drinking charges while the charge for failing to display two license plates on the vehicle he was driving was dismissed.

In addition to the three-year probation and the $140 fine he received for the driving under the influence charge, the court required him to complete a three-month first-offender alcohol program, victim impact counseling, and participate in self-help meetings for one year.

Hillsong Church said Houston violated the church’s pastoral code of conduct by entering the hotel room of an unidentified woman for 40 minutes while under the influence of alcohol and prescription drugs during the church’s annual conference in 2019.

Houston doesn’t recall having sex with the woman, and the woman has not said if they had sex. Their accounts of what happened are not entirely reliable because they were impaired by alcohol, Dooley suggested in meeting with church staffers last Friday. Houston was also under the influence of anxiety medication.  

Houston also exchanged an “inappropriate text message” with a staffer in 2013. According to Dooley, the text message was “along the lines of, ‘If I was with you I would like to give you a kiss and a cuddle or a hug.’The staffer resigned shortly after. Hillsong Church blamed Houston’s actions in this case on “sleeping tablets.”

==========================

Houston's troubles seem to reflect troubles with Hillsong leadership around the world. Conspiracy theorists like me tend to wonder what doors were left open for Satan to so attack so many leaders of Hillsong churches. 


Carl Lentz, who led Hillsong Church in New York City and oversaw the East Coast operation of the megachurch in the United States, was fired in November 2020 over “leadership issues” and moral failures, including being unfaithful to his wife.

A month later, officials in the U.S. branch of the church confirmed with The Christian Post that they investigated and took action on a 2018 letter of complaint alleging inappropriate sexual relations between staff and volunteers at the Hillsong NYC location.

Then in February 2021, Anna Crenshaw, the daughter of a Pennsylvania pastor, reported that Hillsong staff administrator Jason Mays, a married volunteer singer and the son of the church’s head of human resources, sexually assaulted her at a social gathering while she attended Hillsong College in Australia. It took a serious fight from Crenshaw and her father to prosecute Mays, who is still listed as creative director and head of sync at Hillsong Music.


Crenshaw argued that Mays should have been fired. But in commenting on the case, Houston argued that “the Lord has forgiven Jason,” and he is just not a “sexual predator.”

“The Lord has forgiven Jason and we felt he deserved another chance after we weighed up the judge’s findings and comments. As well as giving consideration to the suspension Jason had served and the conditions he had met,” Houston said.

“He was restored to paid work and volunteering, which we believe to be in line with biblical principles of discipline and restoration. One thing I do know is that we are not talking about a sexual predator here. We’re talking about a young man, young married man who did something stupid. Got much drunker than he should, which is an issue that we should keep addressing, and got himself in a bad situation.”

In April 2021, it was revealed that former Hillsong Dallas Lead Pastor Reed Bogard and his wife, Jess, were under investigation for leadership failures when they abruptly resigned in January of that year, resulting in a pause of the Texas campus.

In May 2021, Darnell Barrett, creative director of Hillsong Church Montclair in New Jersey, resigned after claiming he accidentally sent explicit photos to a former church volunteer and confessed that he was unfaithful to his wife.

Other evidence, reviewed by CP, also suggests that Hillsong Church has fended off much more serious allegations of sexual misconduct by at least one former leader.

In their statement Wednesday, Hillsong Church leaders acknowledged that they still had much work to do concerning their governance structure and asked for prayers.

“As you can appreciate, there is still much to be done and our church leadership continues seeking God for His wisdom as we set the course for the future,” the statement said. “We acknowledge that change is needed. We have committed to an independent review of our governance structure and processes, understanding that this is a time of humble reflection and we are committed to doing what is necessary to ensure God is honored, and our eyes are fixed on Jesus.”


====================================================================================


Friday, 3 May 2024

Wolves Among the Sheep > Hillsong needs an awakening after pressing sex assault victim to lie

 

Anna Crenshaw rejects Hillsong’s offer after

megachurch allegedly asked her to sign NDA, lie

A legal agreement that was being brokered between Hillsong Church Australia and former member and ex-Hillsong College student Anna Crenshaw to settle a lawsuit over the harm she suffered from being indecently assaulted by a married church administrator in 2016 fell through Thursday. Crenshaw alleges that Hillsong asked her to lie and sign a non-disclosure agreement.

“We were unable to come to a settlement today because Hillsong changed their plan in a ploy to intimidate and silence me. And I will not give up my voice. This has never been about money for me but about justice and accountability, which we’ve not received this week,” Crenshaw told reporters outside an Australian court Thursday.

On Monday, just over three years after she went public about being indecently assaulted by married Hillsong Church administrator Jason Mays, Crenshaw's attorney announced they had reached an undisclosed settlement agreement with the megachurch for the harm she suffered as a result of the assault.

The settlement was expected to head off a five-day trail which is now back in play. Crenshaw, who is the daughter of Victory Church Senior Pastor Ed Crenshaw in Pennsylvania, said she was disheartened when the church asked her to sign an NDA as part of the settlement and also asked that she release a joint statement saying the church had immediately reported her assault to local police when she came forward, even though it took the church five months.

“There is so much shame that comes with these types of abuses and victims shouldn’t feel shame. I worked so hard in finding my voice in coming forward from my initial report to Hillsong and they have from day one tried to silence me,” Crenshaw said. “That is not what I was seeking in the justice process. It wasn’t to come here, get their money, and walk away without my voice,” Crenshaw said. “It was to get some accountability and a real sense of justice and hope that they would really change in moving forward. I think this is just evidence that despite their new leadership, they have the same tactics.”

Crenshaw was just 18 in 2016 when she says Mays, who was then serving as a Hillsong staff administrator and volunteer singer, sexually assaulted her at a social gathering in Australia. Crenshaw and her father said it took a serious fight from them to hold Mays accountable. He eventually pleaded guilty to indecent assault.

Where is the fear of God here? Lying, and counselling to lie are Satanic practices, not Christian. Hillsong needs an awakening of godly morals.



Wednesday, 1 May 2024

Wolves Among the Sheep > Sexual Assault incident between 18y/o and married Hillsong administrator settled

 

Philadelphia pastor’s daughter, settles lawsuit

with Hillsong Church over sexual assault

Crenshaw, who is the daughter of Victory Church Senior Pastor Ed Crenshaw in Pennsylvania, was embarking on a five-day civil trial against the Australian arm of the megachurch in the NSW Supreme Court on Monday when Hillsong Church decided to broker the deal.

“I’m able to inform the court in principle that the matter has resolved,” Crenshaw’s attorney Kelvin Andrews told the court after an adjournment of the trial which lasted several hours, according to The Australian.

Crenshaw was just 18 in 2018 when she says Jason Mays, who was then serving as a Hillsong staff administrator and volunteer singer, sexually assaulted her at a social gathering in Australia. It took a serious fight from Crenshaw and her father to hold Mays accountable, but he eventually pleaded guilty to indecent assault.

“Jason grabbed me, putting his hand between my legs and his head on my stomach and began kissing my stomach. I felt his arms and hands wrapped around my legs making contact with my inner thigh, butt and crotch,” she wrote in a 2018 statement reviewed by The Christian Post.

She said she told Margaret Aghajanian, Hillsong Church’s then head of pastoral care oversight, that Mays — the son of John Mays, the church’s then head of human resources — had assaulted her, but her complaint was minimized.

“I felt like I could not say anything about the Jason incident because his friend had said not to, insisting that he was a good guy, and this was not a normal behavior for him. After the incident until now I feel uncomfortable when I come into the same area as him,” Crenshaw said in her statement to Aghajanian.

If she didn’t have a strong support network, Crenshaw told CP she wouldn't have been able to get Mays to plead guilty to “assault with an act of indecency” in 2019.

In her claims against Hillsong Church, Crenshaw alleges the charismatic church breached its duty of care to her after the assault she suffered. She also sued Mays as well as Hillsong College.

For his assault of Crenshaw, Mays was placed on two years' probation with no conviction recorded against his name.

"The claim against the church relates to how it responded to the report, including managing the plaintiff's welfare," Gillian Mahoney, a lawyer for Hillsong Church, told 9 News.

While Hillsong Church did not immediately respond to a request for further comment, Mays' lawyer Angus Macinnis said there was a dispute about what happened to Crenshaw and the extent of the injuries she suffered.

Mahoney said what Mays did to Crenshaw was a "single, fleeting, spontaneous,” moment. He also said Crenshaw’s initial account of the assault was presented as somewhat "less serious" than it is being presented now.

That's not unususal. The point is, it shouldn't have happened at all. He was married, he was a church administrator; he should never be in a position like that again.



Monday, 28 August 2023

Wolves Among the Sheep > Hillsong's Brian Houston found 'Not Guilty'! Two Suicides by Pastors in Nigeria

..

Hillsong founder Brian Houston found not guilty of covering up

father's gay child sexual abuse

By Clyde Hughes

Brian Houston, founder of the Australian megachurch Hillsong, arrives at the Downing Center Local Court in Sydney, Australia, on Thursday. Photo by Bianca de Marchi/EPA-EFE
I wonder what he was thinking? Those eyes are a little disturbing.


Aug. 17 (UPI) -- Australian megachurch founder Brian Houston was found not guilty on Thursday of hiding his father's sexual abuse of a child years before.

Magistrate Gareth Christofi ruled that 69-year-old Hillsong founder Brian Houston had a "reasonable excuse" for not reporting the allegations against his father, late Assemblies of God pastor Frank Houston, he believed he was respecting the wishes of the victim Brett Sengstock.

"There is little doubt in my view that the accused knew or believed on reasonable grounds that Brett Sengstock did not want the matter reported to the police," Christofi said.

Brian Houston, who pleaded not guilty to charges of concealing a serious indictable offense said he learned in 1999 that his father abused Sengstock when he was 7. The younger Houston said he was left "speechless" about the revelation by Sengstock who was 30 at the time.

Sengstock testified that he did not want others to know about the abuse, calling it a "hideous secret."

"Frank Houston was no pioneer for Christianity; his legacy remains a faded memory of a pedophile," Sengstock said. "Regardless of today's outcome, I have received a life sentence."

The magistrate said Sengstock was paid $10,000 after meeting with Frank Houston in late 1999 or early 2000, during which he signed a napkin and was told to contact Brian Houston if he did not receive the money.

Christofi did admonish Brian Houston for being involved in the payment of Sengstock, which he saw as a "hush money" payment than a form of financial compensation for what the victim went through.

He noted, however, that Brian Houston took part in a 2003 interview in which he said his father confessed to the abuse which was reported to church elders and the wider congregation and later discussed in sermons.

The magistrate said this was a sign that he did not try to hide his father's crimes.

"The obvious conclusion to draw ... is that he wanted people to know about it," Christofi said. "That is the very opposite of a cover-up."

During the trial, Brian Houston said additional victims from New Zealand had come forward around the same time as Sengstock and that the full extent of his father's abuse may remain unclear.

"He was obviously a serial pedophile," he said. "We probably will never know the extent of his pedophilia and a lot of people's lives have been tragically hurt and for that I'll always be very sad."




Pastor dies by suicide after girlfriend rejects marriage proposal


Another Nigerian pastor suicides after being accused of misappropriation of church funds


By Anugrah Kumar, Christian Post Contributor

Chris Hondros/Getty Images


A young pastor in Nigeria’s Anambra State jumped from a two-story building and died, reportedly after his girlfriend rejected his marriage proposal. He was pronounced dead at the scene, according to reports.

Identified as Pastor Prosper Obum Igboke, the 30-year-old man led a Pentecostal church in the Nnewi area of Anambra State, Nigerian Tribune reported Saturday, citing a relative who said the pastor took the fatal leap last month after his girlfriend, whom he had financially supported through university, declined his proposal for marriage.

The same relative expressed surprise that “a man of this age and a pastor can do this.

Pastor Igboke was a native of Leru community in Umunneochi Local Government Area, Abia State. According to the tradition of the Leru autonomous community, individuals who die by suicide are buried in a forest as an act of “sacrilege.”

Igboke was buried last Friday in a bush in his community, the relative was quoted as saying.

The state police spokesman, DSP Tochukwu Ikenga, told media the incident had not been reported to the police command.

“There is no information like that before me, and I want to also thank you for the privileged information. I will escalate this to the police manager within the area for necessary action,” Ikenga said in a statement to Punch.

The deceased had reportedly seen his girlfriend through university, investing emotionally and financially in her education. The relative who spoke to journalists said the rejection came as a disappointment to Igboke, leading to his drastic action. This information was consistent across reports from the Nigerian Tribune, Punch and Daily Post.

The incident has raised questions about the societal pressures and expectations that may have contributed to this tragic event. However, as of now, the police have not initiated an official investigation into the matter.

In a separate incident in January 2016, a 49-year-old Nigerian pastor named Bassey died by suicide in his Lagos home, according to News Break. Bassey had been accused by his church members of misusing church funds for personal gain.

The accusation led to his depression and withdrawal. On the night of his death, he stayed on the balcony until 3 a.m. before his wife convinced him to go to bed. Unbeknownst to her, he had hidden a knife under the bed. He used it to slash his throat at 5 a.m. Bassey left a suicide note stating, “I, Myself, not my wife.”

Pastors who misuse church funds, or who suicide because of rejection, have not surrendered their lives to Jesus Christ. Consequently, their ambitions open the door for Satan to enter in and tempt them to suicide. These tragedies are not societal in origin, they are an example of men who should not be pastors. 



Saturday, 17 December 2022

Wolves Among the Sheep > Brian Houston's Trial hears Frank preached after losing credentials; Anglican Pastor Guilty of Felony CSA

..

Frank Houston continued to lead sermons after being stripped of credentials

for child sexual abuse, court hears


Maitland church pastor Robert Cotton said he would never have allowed Frank Houston

to preach again if he knew he was a paedophile


Hillsong founder Brian Houston (pictured) has pleaded not guilty to a charge of concealing a serious indictable offence of another person, relating to his father, Frank. Photograph: Bianca de Marchi/AAP
Australian Associated Press

Thu 15 Dec 2022 09.18 GMT

Paedophile pastor Frank Houston continued leading church sermons until weeks before his death, despite being stripped of his credentials to minister after his son learned that he sexually abused children, a New South Wales court has heard.

Hillsong founder Brian Houston took away his father’s credentials in late 1999 after Frank Houston admitted he had abused children, the court has heard.

However eight weeks before Frank Houston died in 2004, he was still ministering, leading a sermon at a church in the NSW Hunter region, the court heard on Thursday.

In case you were wondering whether Frank was truly repentant for his evils, this would cast serious doubt upon it.

Alleged confession of abuse by Frank Houston came when his son, Hillsong founder Brian Houston, raised allegations in 2000.

Brian Houston, 68, has pleaded not guilty to concealing his father’s crime, arguing the person his father admitted to abusing did not want an investigation, and was an adult who could have reported it to police themselves by the time he found out.

Maitland church pastor Robert Cotton told Brian Houston’s trial on Thursday that Frank Houston was “at his best” as a preacher and entertainer when he led a sermon weeks before he was stripped of his credentials.

Over the next few years Cotton tried to have him return to the church again, unaware of his offending, and said he was told that Frank Houston was not taking bookings, Cotton told the Downing Centre local court. Cotton said he did not ask why.

“If you had been told no by the Houstons you didn’t question it,” he said.

Cotton said he never would have allowed Frank Houston to preach again in 2004 if he knew he was a paedophile.

Greg Morris, the former business manager of the church Frank Houston and his wife, Hazel, joined on the Central Coast, told the court there was a sense of honour about the pair attending.

And there was an absence of discernment!

Frank Houston was widely known in Pentecostal churches. “Godfather’s not the right term, but [he was] highly revered … highly respected,” Morris said.

Frank Houston gave three or four sermons and prayed for those attending in late 2002 and early 2003, Morris said. Young people were also present at the “family church” when Frank Houston ministered, Morris said.

Morris was the church’s contact with the NSW Office of the Children’s Guardian. He said he did not learn Frank Houston was a paedophile until after his death.

Morris told the court he believed the “moral failure” he learned of related to adults, thinking Frank Houston may have cheated on his wife, a “not uncommon” reason a pastor might lose their credential to minister.

Brian Houston’s lawyer, Phillip Boulten SC, said those within the Central Coast church who attended the 2002 Hillsong conference would have heard Brian Houston addressing his father’s abuse in a sermon, prior to him preaching at the church.

Morris said some church congregants typically attended the conference but maintained he had heard nothing about child sexual abuse.

Brian Houston also gave media interviews addressing his father’s abuse after his death.

In a press conference played to the court, Brian Houston said he was unaware of any requirement to report a crime when he learned of the abuse.

In another interview with 2GB broadcaster Ben Fordham he explained why he didn’t report to authorities in 1999 on behalf of the abuse survivor, who was by then an adult.

“I just genuinely believed that … if he wants to go to the police he can go to the police,” Brian Houston said in a recording played to the court.

He said his father’s days as a minister were over after he learned of the abuse in 1999 and took action against him.

“He never preached again, anywhere,” Brian Houston said.

The hearing continues.




Mark Rivera, a former Anglican lay pastor, found guilty

of felony child sexual assault


The decision has been a long time coming for the family of Cherin Marie, whose

young daughter originally reported being sexually abused by Rivera in 2019.


Booking photos of Mark Rivera. Photos courtesy of Kane County Sheriff’s Office

December 15, 2022
By Kathryn Post

(RNS) — Mark Rivera, a former lay pastor at the center of several sexual abuse allegations in a conservative Anglican denomination, was found guilty of five counts of felony child sexual abuse and assault on Thursday morning (Dec. 15).

Judge John Barsanti of Illinois’ 16th Judicial Circuit Court in Kane County found Rivera guilty of two counts of predatory sexual assault of a victim under 13 years old (a Class X felony) and three counts of aggravated criminal sexual abuse of a victim under 13 (a Class 2 felony). The defense has 30 days to file a motion to request a new trial, and if the motion is denied, the sentencing hearing is expected to take place on Feb. 10. Barsanti revoked Rivera’s bail, and Rivera will be held at Kane County jail awaiting the final outcome of the prosecution.

The decision has been a long time coming for the family of Cherin Marie, whose young daughter originally reported being sexually abused by Rivera in 2019. Cherin asked to go by her first and middle names to protect her family’s privacy.

“We are grateful for the verdict and we hope this is the first step of many towards justice for Mark Rivera’s victims,” Cherin said on behalf of her family. 

Rivera served as a lay minister at a church plant of the Anglican Church in North America in Big Rock, Illinois, from 2013-2019. He was initially arrested in 2019 and charged in connection with his crimes against Cherin’s daughter, who attended the church plant with Cherin and her family. Rivera has since been accused of abusing more than 10 other alleged survivors, and has also been charged with two felony counts of criminal sexual assault.

The three-day bench trial — a trial decided by a judge, not a jury — took place over the span of three months at the Kane County Judicial Center on July 12, Sept. 2 and Oct. 16.

Julia Petersen, an ACNA member who attended the first day of the trial in solidarity with the reported survivors, told Religion News Service that seeing Cherin’s daughter give her testimony was profoundly moving. “I have never seen courage like I’ve seen that day,” she said.

Matthew Rodgers, an attorney from the Kane County State’s Attorney Office who represented the people of Illinois in this case, told RNS in an email that the prosecutors took on this case because “we and the grand jury found the victim and the allegations to be credible.” He said the defense’s main argument was that the state had insufficient evidence. Rivera’s lawyer, Brittany Pedersen, did not respond to multiple requests for comment.

Earlier this year, the anti-abuse advocacy group ACNAtoo reported that the criminal trial was originally planned for December 2020 but faced several delays. “For nearly two years, this young girl has repeatedly steeled herself to face her abuser in court, only to have the trial delayed again every time,” they wrote in September.

Judges should not allow that to happen, it's unfair to the victim. But, I guess the victim doesn't have the same rights as the rapist.

“We are grateful that today’s guilty verdict marks the beginning of justice for this courageous young girl and her family. Let justice roll down for all of Mark Rivera’s victims,” ACNAtoo said today in a statement to RNS. 

Christ Our Light Anglican Church


The Anglican Church in North America formed in 2009 after splitting from the Episcopal Church and the Anglican Church of Canada over the two denominations’ acceptance of LGBTQ clergy and same-sex marriage. Leadership in the young denomination’s Upper Midwest Diocese, where the Christ Our Light Anglican church plant was located, has been roiled by accusations of mishandling sexual abuse allegations for over a year. Spokespeople for ACNA and the diocese did not respond to requests for comment.

Katie Robichaud, a former member of Church of the Resurrection — the Upper Midwest Diocese’s headquarters and the onetime church home of Rivera — attended the second day of the trial. She told RNS she’s worried church leaders still may not take the reality of sexual abuse in the church seriously.

“The concern I have is that the province, or the diocese or the local church Rez, will try, consciously or not, to interpret this as an exception and a fluke instead of a giant warning sign that if it’s not taken seriously, immediately, that it’s just a matter of time before we repeat this whole scenario.”

In May, Cherin Marie filed a lawsuit against Christ Our Light Anglican Church, the now defunct church plant where Rivera was lay pastor, arguing that her daughter has experienced mental anguish and emotional and physical pain because of the church’s negligence. The lawsuit requests over $50,000 in damages. Evan Smola, a lawyer who is representing Cherin in the civil case, says the guilty verdict likely will not impact the lawsuit.

“Because the burdens of proof are different criminally than they are civilly, the outcomes of criminal cases are generally not admissible in a civil case,” he told RNS.

Rivera is still awaiting trial in the Kane County circuit court for charges related to rape allegations made against him by his former neighbor, Joanna Rudenborg. She told RNS in an email that Thursday’s guilty verdict demonstrates that “the State, if not the Church, takes the serial sexual assault of a 9-year-old child seriously.”

“Every conviction of a serial abuser brings a sigh of relief and some sense of justice for the survivors watching,” Rudenborg told RNS. “I know there are still a lot of Mark Riveras out there. But my mind would be put greatly at ease to know that the specific one who shattered the lives of so many people I love, that at least he is finally somewhere where he cannot hurt people so easily.”



Thursday, 3 November 2022

Wolves Among the Sheep > 4 JW Pervs - 19 Minor Victims; Elder Murders Wife for Gay Lover; Hillsong Founder Fighting in Court

..

Pa. Attorney General Josh Shapiro announces charges against

four JWs for sexual abuse of 19 minors

BY SHELLEY BORTZ
OCTOBER 27, 2022 / 11:27 AM / CBS PITTSBURGH

HARRISBURG (KDKA) - Pennsylvania Attorney General Josh Shapiro has announced criminal charges against four men in Pennsylvania for the sexual abuse of children across the Commonwealth. 

Jesse Hill, a former resident of Berks County now a resident of Georgia; Jose Serrano of Lancaster County; Eric Eleam of Butler County; and Robert Ostrander, a former resident of Cambria County, now a resident of New York, are all charged for the sexual assault and exploitation of children. 

All of the defendants' victims were minors, as well as members of Jehovah's Witness congregations. 

"These cases are disturbing, the allegations hard to imagine, and all share one common tie - the 19 victims and the four men who are being charged with sexually violating them are all members of Jehovah's Witnesses," AG Shapiro said. "These children deserved to be protected and grow up in peace, not to be preyed upon. My office will not stop until these defendants are held accountable for their crimes against innocent children and until justice is achieved for these courageous survivors."

Serrano is accused of molesting his own daughter, along with five other young girls in 2011. He is facing charges of aggravated indecent assault, indecent assault, and endangering the welfare of children. 

Hill is accused of using his milling business to attract young boys from the congregation with promises of alcohol, marijuana, and pornography in the 1990s. He allegedly exposed himself to the children, groped them, and forced them to perform oral sex. He is facing charges of rape, involuntary deviant sexual intercourse, indecent assault, and the corruption of minors. 

Ostrander is accused of sexually abusing at least two minors, including his own stepdaughter. He is facing charges of indecent assault, endangering the welfare of children, and corruption of minors. 

Eleam is accused of sexually abusing his daughter and using sexual molestation as a form of punishment when she was a child. He is facing charges of rape, involuntary deviant sexual intercourse, aggravated indecent assault, and endangering the welfare of a child. 

When officers attempted to take Eleam into custody, he took his own life. 

Charges were filed in Lancaster, Berks, and Cambria counties. Those charges all stem from a grand jury and the investigation found that these men in total abused and exploited 19 minors. 




Elder convicted of killing wife attended church of pastor

who cursed congregation for Movado watch


It seems he murdered his wife because he was in love with a gay man. Good grief!


By Leonardo Blair,
Senior Features Reporter
The Christian Post

Elder Robert Harris, 30 (L), of Repairers Kansas City church in Missouri, is accused of murdering his late wife, Tanisha, 38 (R). She was an associate minister. | (Photo: Facebook)


Robert Harris, a former church elder charged with killing his wife after less than two years of marriage, has been convicted of first-degree murder.

Harris, who served as an elder at Repairers Kansas City, a charismatic non-denominational church in Missouri, was convicted last Friday of killing his then 38-year-old wife, Tanisha on Jan. 8, 2018. He is scheduled to be sentenced on Nov. 3, The Associated Press reported.

Overland Park police say that at about 4 p.m. on the day of the murder, they were called to an apartment in the 8000 block of Perry Street about a domestic disturbance.

Harris was found alone in the apartment, but several hours later, he called the police to report that his wife was missing. When he was further questioned, officers became suspicious and admitted he had something to do with her disappearance. Tanisha Harris' body was later found in a field in Raymore. Her husband was taken into custody.

Several people gave testimony at Harris' trial at the Johnson County District Court, including a young man who testified that he was involved in a romantic relationship with the former church elder and Army veteran.

Steven Junior (pictured) testified that he was in a romantic relationship with former Elder Robert Harris, who was convicted of killing his wife. | YouTube/Dawson Speaks TV

The young man publicly identified himself as Steven Junior. In an intense, expletive-filled video recording on Facebook Live, he said he wanted justice for Harris' wife, who he said was a longtime friend.

He also accused congregants at Harris' church, where controversial pastor Carlton Funderburke served as lead pastor, of being hypocrites.

Pastor Carlton Funderburke | Screengrab: YouTube/Church at The Well Kansas City

Funderburke, who now leads Church at the Well Kansas City with his wife, was recently forced to apologize after he was shown in a now-viral video clip throwing a spiritualized tantrum from the pulpit in which he called his congregation "broke, busted and disgusted" and "cheap sons and daughters" for not "honoring" him with a watch from the luxury brand Movado. 

"That's how I know you're still poor, broke, busted and disgusted because of how you've been honoring me. I'm not worth your McDonald's money? I'm not worth your Red Lobster money? I ain't worth your St. John Knits? Y'all can't afford it no how," Funderburke, who is married with three children, lamented over his congregation's refusal to buy him a watch from the luxury brand that ranges in price from $300 to more than $3,000.

Former elder Robert Harris (C) poses with his former pastor, Carlton Funderburke (Front L) and other young men from Repairers Kansas City. | YouTube/Dawson Speaks TV

Funderburke has since apologized for the video.

In an interview discussing Harris' arrest shortly after Tanisha Harris' murder, Funderburke, who presided over their wedding, said he was devastated and could never have predicted such an outcome for their relationship. 

"They were a loving couple. ... They were a wonderful newlywed couple," he said.

"They were very involved, very engaged, active in the community of church. These were not regular attenders or regular parishioners," he added. "They're part of the background of what we do as a ministry. ... It's very shocking."




Hillsong Church founder Brian Houston set to fight charge of

concealing his father’s child sex abuse

news.com.au
By: Adelaide Lang and Lauren Ferri
2 Nov, 2022 05:36 PM

Brian Houston will face court before Christmas to fight the charge that he hid his father’s sexual abuse. Photo / Marcus Ingram

Hillsong Church founder Brian Houston will face court to fight allegations he covered up his father’s child sexual abuse.

The 68-year-old appeared in Sydney Downing Centre Local Court after pleading not guilty to concealing the serious indictable offence of another person.

Police allege the megachurch founder has known since September 1999 that his father Frank Houston had indecently assaulted a young male in 1970.

Police claim Houston failed to inform authorities despite believing his father had committed the assault and knowing he had information that could be of use to the prosecution.

He is charged with withholding that information from September 15, 1999, to the day after his father’s death on November 8, 2004.

Mr Houston has vehemently denied the allegation, telling the church at the beginning of the year that the charge was a “complete shock” and he was prepared to “vigorously defend it”.

On Thursday, the court was told he would proceed to a special three-week hearing to fight the charge.

The court was told the hearing was set to proceed on December 2 and run until December 22, just before the courts break for Christmas.

The Crown prosecutor requested a remote room for witnesses to give evidence without needing to be present in court, as well as an audio visual link for witnesses who were unable to give evidence in person.

Mr Houston is no longer a pastor at the Hillsong Church, which he founded in the Sydney suburbs in 1983. The church has since expanded to 30 countries.




Friday, 25 March 2022

Wolves Among the Sheep > Sex Harassment at Christianity Today; Houston, We have a Problem, or 2, or 3, as Hillsong comes apart at the seams

..

Former Christianity Today Editor, Advertising Director

Accused of Sexual Harassment

Amanda Casanova | 
ChristianHeadlines.com Contributor | 
Wednesday, March 16, 2022



Christianity Today has admitted that it failed to pursue consequences for two ministry leaders accused of sexual harassment at its Carol Stream, Illinois, office.

In its own report, Christianity Today, an evangelical Christian magazine, said “a number of women” reported “demeaning, inappropriate, and offensive behavior” from former editor-in-chief Mark Galli and former advertising director Olatokunbo Olawoye.

The two men were not investigated or disciplined, according to an external assessment of the ministry’s culture.

“We want to practice the transparency and accountability we preach,” said CT president Timothy Dalrymple. “It’s imperative we be above reproach on these matters. If we’re falling short of what love requires of us, we want to know, and we want to do better.”

How did you not practice that years ago?

Eight women said Galli touched them inappropriately, including one former employee who said he caressed her bare shoulder during an event. Another woman said Galli rubbed her back and got his hand “stuck under her bra.”

Three women reported to human resources that Galli had inappropriately touched them, and in 2019 he was reprimanded.

According to Christianity Today, the 2019 event was not the first time Galli had been reported to HR.

From the mid-2000s to 2019, about six employees reported harassment from Galli or Olawoye, but there was no formal report, warning or reprimand.

“The culture when I was there was to protect the institution at all costs,” said Amy Jackson, an associate publisher who left what she said had become a hostile work environment in 2018. “No one was ever held accountable. Mark Galli was certainly protected.”

Galli, however, told the Religion News Service that the claims were false or taken out of context. He told CT that he may have “crossed lines,” but he never had “any romantic or sexual interest in anyone at Christianity Today.”

Then why did you 'cross lines'? 

He said he was “deeply troubled” by the accusations and said he would be open to meeting with people to apologize.

Meanwhile, Richard Shields, CT’s HR director from 2008 to 2019, said HR did what it was supposed to do.

“I always took complaints seriously and very, very confidentially,” he told the CT news editor. “I’m very confident that we used the processes we had in place very consistently, very thoroughly, very effectively.”

Your definition of 'very effectively' may differ from the victims. It may also differ from God's.

The incidents included many one-on-one meetings with the men. During those meetings, Olawoye would reportedly sometimes say he wasn’t attracted to his wife and compliment other women. In another case, one woman told her manager that Olawoye was staring at her breasts during meetings. The manager’s response: “It helps if you wear a scarf.”

Olawoye was arrested in 2017 after a sting operation by federal agents. He had been trying to pay for sex with a teenager and was later sentenced to three years in prison. He is out of prison and living in Chicago as a registered sex offender.

He did not respond to requests for comment.

I'll bet he didn't. And if he did, you probably couldn't print it.

Christian organizations need to hire people who have an intimate relationship with Jesus Christ, not just an ability to market products. It's so sad that worldly abilities seem to trump spiritual relationships.




Hillsong Founder Brian Houston Accused of

Behaving Inappropriately Toward 2 Women

Milton Quintanilla | 
Contributor for ChristianHeadlines.com | 
Friday, March 18, 2022


A leaked letter issued to Hillsong members on Friday states that founder Brian Houston breached its code of conduct after two women alleged Houston of inappropriate behavior.

The Hillsong Global Board sent the letter to Hillsong members following a video conference between interim Global Senior Pastor Phil Dooley and 800 global members concerning Houston's 'indiscretions' between 2013 and 2019.

"We have sadly been dealing with two complaints made against Pastor Brian over the last 10 years," the board said.

"We apologise unreservedly to the people affected by Pastor Brian's actions and commit to being available for any further assistance we can provide."

The letter, which was leaked to ABC News Australia, alleges that Houston sent "inappropriate" text messages to a former female staffer.

Dooley, who was emotional during the meeting, said that Houston's message was along the lines of "'If I was with you, I would like to give you a kiss and a cuddle or a hug,' words of that nature."

He added that Houston at the time was "under the influence of sleeping tablets, upon which he had developed a dependence."

"He immediately apologised to the person," Dooley said. "We also worked with Pastor Brian to ensure he received professional help to eliminate his dependency on this medication, and this was achieved successfully."

The female staffer, who resigned after receiving those messages from Houston, issued a complaint to Hillsong general manager George Aghajanian. After resigning, the woman was unable to find work outside of Hillsong, so Houston compensated her with "a couple of months' salary" out of his own pocket.

The second incident took place in 2019 when an intoxicated Houston spent nearly an hour with another woman inside a hotel room. At the time, Houston had been drinking with other Hillsong figures during its annual conference in Qudos Bank Arena in Homebush, New South Wales.

"Later that evening, Pastor Brian attempted to get into his room but didn't have his room key and ended up knocking on the door to the woman's room," Dooley noted.

The woman, who was not a member of Hillsong, opened the door and let Houston in.

"The truth is, we don't know what happened next," Dooley continued. "The woman has not said there was any sexual activity. Brian has said there was no sexual activity, but he was in the room for 40 minutes."

Following an investigation into the incident, the board found that Houston "became disorientated ... following the consumption of anti-anxiety medication beyond the prescribed dose, mixed with alcohol."

"Ultimately, the board found that Brian had breached the Hillsong Pastor's Code of Conduct," the board said.

In response, Houston paid for the woman's conference fee and returned her "Kingdom Builder" donation. The Hillsong founder also pledged to take three months off from ministry and abstain from alcohol, but "he didn't abide by that," Dooley said.

"He did conduct some ministry, I believe on three separate occasions... and he also did, as he would say, consume some alcohol," he added.

Dooley also dismissed allegations of cover-ups of the incidents, asserting that the board handled them "appropriately under the circumstances of the information given to them and with a desire to see Brian healthy."

During the meeting, Dooley stressed the importance of extending grace in light of Christ instead of exposing anyone. He also emphasized that anyone attending Hillsong should feel safe and should not have to fear facing "any form of abuse or harassment."

"We're deeply sorry for those victims and for what they've had to go through and what they've had to endure," he said.

Dooley acknowledged that Houston "has made significant mistakes" and asked for prayers for the Houston family at this time.

"Sin is messy, and it brings all kinds of pain," he concluded.

Earlier this year, Houston stepped down as Hillsong's Global Leader to challenge a criminal charge of concealment of his father's child sexual abuse.

The recent news adds to a line of scandals seen at Hillsong over the past several years.

Search this blog for 'Hillsong' for several other stories.

Several years ago I was delighted to find services from Hillsong Australia on TV. The song service was wonderful, and then Houston began to preach. I couldn't listen to the whole sermon, nor have I ever watched another Hillsong service since. Don't know what it was about him that I didn't like, but there was definitely something.




Satan likes to get in on the ground floor of any new Christian movement, and there has been none bigger in the past 30 years than Hillsong. Brian's father, Frank, was a gay paedophile, and it was he who began the church in Sydney that Brian would later turn into the first Hillsong. How this affected the many megachurches that later formed under the Hillsong banner is open to debate, but there seems to be a remarkable number of senior pastors having to step down because of sexual indiscretions. (See, also, 2nd and 3rd stories below).


Hillsong Founder Brian Houston Resigns as Global Senior Pastor


Milton Quintanilla | 
Contributor for ChristianHeadlines.com | 
Thursday, March 24, 2022

The resignation, which comes following recent revelations that Houston engaged in inappropriate behavior with two women, was confirmed by Hillsong’s board on Wednesday. Hillsong, founded by Brian and his wife, Bobbi Houston, in 1983, grew to be one of the largest megachurches in the world today, with multiple locations across the globe.


“We understand there will be much emotion at this news, and we all share these feelings. Irrespective of the circumstances around this, we can all agree that Brian and Bobbie have served God faithfully over many decades and that their ministry has resulted in millions of people across the world being impacted by the power, grace, and love of Jesus Christ,”
the board said in a statement.

“Hillsong Church was birthed out of Brian and Bobbie’s obedience and commitment to the call of God, and we are extremely grateful for all that Brian and Bobbie have given to build His house. We ask that you continue to pray for them, and the entire Houston family, during this challenging time.”

The board also announced that it will be undergoing “an independent review” of its “governance structure and processes,” adding that “this is a time of humble reflection, and we are committed to doing what is necessary to ensure God is honoured, and our eyes are fixed on Jesus.”

“We value your ongoing support and prayers. We are also praying for our entire church family at this time,” the statement concluded.

As Christian Headlines previously reported, Houston was accused of acting inappropriately towards two women. One of the women, a former Hillsong staffer, accused Houston of sending “inappropriate” text messages to her.

In a separate 2019 incident, Houston reportedly spent 40 minutes inside another woman’s hotel room after losing his room key during Hillsong’s annual conference. At the time, Houston was drunk and had consumed anti-anxiety medication beyond the described dose. According to Houston and the woman, no sexual activity took place.

In a statement last week, the Hillsong board confirmed that they had been dealing with these complaints “over the last ten years.” Following an investigation, they concluded that Houston had “breached the Hillsong Pastor’s Code of Conduct.”

Houston initially agreed to step down from his leadership role for a time but “failed to take all of the agreed steps which resulted in further action being taken by the board in late 2021,” the board added.

In January, Houston stepped down from his duties as global senior pastor to focus on legal charges he was facing for allegedly concealing his father’s sexual abuse of children. Taking Houston’s place are interim leaders Pastors Phil and Lucinda Dooley of Hillsong South Africa.




Former Hillsong Dallas Pastor Reed Bogard resigned

after he was accused of rape, investigation reveals

By Leonardo Blair, 
Senior Features Reporter|
Friday, March 25, 2022

Less than two weeks after Reed Bogard abruptly resigned as lead pastor of the now-defunct Hillsong Dallas in January 2021, an internal investigation commissioned by Hillsong Global showed that the married father of three was accused of rape by a junior female staffer with whom he had a monthlong affair while serving at Hillsong NYC years earlier.


The former junior Hillsong NYC staffer who asked not to be publicly named in this report when contacted by The Christian Post, said she has been trying to move on with her life. She confirmed she participated in a deposition concerning the allegation but would not say anything more than what was already included in the report.

“I think at this stage ... I’m not going to comment. Everything that you have in that deposition is obviously something that I did, and I said in the context of a legal deposition. I think I just want to leave it at that.”

The findings of the investigation conducted by the New York City law firm Zukerman Gore Brandeis & Crossman, LLP, are highlighted in a report reviewed by CP. The investigation was commissioned by Hillsong Global in October 2020, shortly after senior church officials first learned that the former junior staffer alleged that her first act of sexual intercourse with Bogard in his car after a late night out together was non-consensual. 

Hillsong leaders were made aware years earlier of a sexual relationship between the two parties, but an investigation was not conducted by the church at the time. Church leaders were led to believe the relationship was consensual and "consequences to both [parties] were meted out accordingly," investigators revealed.

The report was submitted to George Aghajanian, general manager and a director of Hillsong Church Australia and its international entities, on Jan. 11, 2021.

It shows that Hillsong Church Australia first learned of the sexual affair between Bogard and the junior staff member in the second half of 2014. The relationship began in September 2013 and continued through the beginning of January 2014.

“At the time, the Church did not conduct any meaningful inquiry into the details or circumstances of the affair, and no one with appropriate training was assigned to look into matters,” investigators noted.

When contacted about the report in February, Hillsong Church said Brian Houston, who resigned Wednesday after it was revealed that two women made serious complaints of misconduct against him in the last 10 years, was not aware of the rape claims against Bogard when he was chosen to lead Hillsong Dallas in 2019. Houston is currently facing criminal charges for allegedly concealing sex abuse committed by his father decades earlier. 

“Brian Houston categorically denies he had knowledge of this serious allegation when Reed Bogard was selected as the Lead Pastor for Dallas,” Hillsong Church said in a statement to CP. “Hillsong Church has enormous compassion for the other party involved in this situation. We have been in regular contact with her and she has asked to remain anonymous. We ask that the media and all other parties respect and protect her privacy.”

As the coronavirus swept the world in late 2020, the church learned that the affair didn’t start out consensually. The report states that the junior staffer "resurfaced the issue" in October 2020, six years after initially confessing to having a consensual relationship. 

“More than six years later, on or about October 2020, Hillsong Church Australia learned of additional allegations concerning Ms. [redacted] and Mr. Bogard’s affair. Specifically, in discussions with certain leaders of Hillsong NYC, Ms. [redacted] asserted to them, apparently for the first time, that her sexual experience with Mr. Bogard, at least initially, had not been consensual,” the report said in a summary. “For the first time, Ms. [redacted] stated that at least in their initial sexual intercourse, Mr. Bogard had raped her.”

Investigators at Zukerman Gore said while it might be too late for Bogard’s accuser to seek civil damages against him or the church for what happened to her, “a criminal complaint for rape might still be timely, though that would not be expected to implicate the Church itself.”

There was no indication from the investigation that the rape allegation was reported to law enforcement. In 2019, New York state extended the state statute of limitations for reporting second-degree rape to 20 years and third-degree rape to 10 years. 

Investigators noted in the report that: "It is difficult if not impossible to say with certainty whether the initial sexual acts between Mr. Bogard and Ms. [redacted] occurred notwithstanding an express, verbal objection ('No') uttered by Ms. [redacted] in the moment."

Zukerman Gore Brandeis & Crossman, LLP, did not respond to requests for comment.

Bogard, who now works as a director of business development for Keller Williams in Michigan, said he was done with all things Hillsong as well.

“I don’t have any comment on that. I’m not going to discuss anything. I have nothing to do with Hillsong anymore. … I haven’t been a part of that organization for over a year,” he said when contacted by CP.

When Houston and his wife, Bobbie, announced they were pausing the Dallas campus in April 2021, they failed to mention that Bogard, 39, had been accused of rape.

“It was very disappointing to learn that, while some of you experienced the Bogards as dedicated pastors, many others have experienced leadership that failed to meet the commitments and standards of Hillsong Church,” Brian Houston said, in part, at the time. “I want to be the first to apologize to those who felt disappointed or hurt, and I pray that God does a swift work in bringing peace and healing.”

In addition to the allegation of rape, which allegedly took place one night on Manhattan’s Upper East Side in October 2013, details highlighted in the report show Bogard drinking heavily, using marijuana, and generally bullying staff while serving at Hillsong NYC prior to being promoted as lead pastor of Hillsong Dallas.

Ben Houston, Brian Houston’s son, who was leading Hillsong LA and serving as Bogard’s boss when the former junior staffer first revealed her sexual relationship with him to Hillsong senior leaders, told investigators that he had spoken with his father and members of the church’s global board about the relationship. Investigators reported that Bogard was "stood down publicly from the platform in Los Angeles for a period of either eight or twelve months," noting that "stories differ."

Houston told the investigators that "the nature and extent of such discipline were handed down by top leadership in Australia," the report reads.

"Thereafter, Mr. Bogard was returned to full Pastoral duties, and was eventually awarded a promotion to Lead Pastor in the newly created Church location in Dallas, Texas," the report adds.

“The board came up with a plan that Mr. Bogard would not be permitted to serve in leadership in any capacity for twelve months, he would not be on platform for 12 months and he would undergo counseling,” investigators said.

Both Bogard and his rape accuser offered varying accounts of their first sexual encounter which happened inside his car on Manhattan’s Upper East Side after they had a clandestine meeting at a local bar, investigators said.

“Ms. [redacted] stated that as soon as she and Mr. Bogard sat down at a table at the bar, they each ordered a drink. Ms. [redacted] recalls that right after giving their drink order, Mr. Bogard leaned in and tried to kiss her. Ms. [redacted] stated that she ‘probably’ participated in the kiss. Ms. [redacted] and Mr. Bogard then talked about Mr. Bogard’s frustrations with his upcoming move to California, and how he was unhappy in his marriage,” the report said.

While this was happening, Bogard’s accuser told investigators that she felt very conflicted being at the bar with him because she felt like she had put herself in that position and had been asking herself, “do I like him?”

“In part, Ms. [redacted] now believes that she went to the bar to satisfy her own curiosity,” investigators said. Bogard claimed that they arranged to meet at the bar around 2 a.m. or 3 a.m.

The former Hillsong junior staffer said they stayed at the bar for about 45 minutes, having only one drink each. Investigators said Bogard disputed the level of drinking.

“Mr. Bogard’s description of the amount of drinking is very different. Mr. Bogard’s position is interesting because he seems to ‘need’ to establish that he was too drunk to act responsibly as a way of soothing his conscience, yet he ignores or overlooks the fact that if Ms. [redacted], his subordinate, was similarly impaired, that she would have been incapable of meaningful consent in what happens after they leave the bar,” investigators explained.

The subordinate staffer recalls Bogard offered her a ride home, but the former pastor told investigators she asked for the ride home.

The alleged rape


Once they were in the car, things quickly got out of hand.

“Ms. [redacted] stated that when they got into the car (she in the front passenger seat and Mr. Bogard in the driver’s seat), Mr. Bogard leaned across the arm rest and kissed Ms. [redacted]. Ms. [redacted] admits that she kissed Mr. Bogard back.

“Mr. Bogard then began to climb over the arm rest until he was bearing down on top of her in her seat. Significantly, Ms. [redacted] now discloses that at the time she said, ‘no, I don’t think we should do this,’” investigators said.

“Ms. [redacted] says that Mr. Bogard ignored her comment and continued his climb on top of her. He then reached down between the seat and the door and pulled the lever that released the seat back. Ms. [redacted] recalled the disoriented falling sensation of the seat back suddenly going back when she’d not realized it was about to do so.

“Ms. [redacted] recalls that at around this point, Mr. Bogard undid his pants. Ms. [redacted] now reports that at this point, she said ‘no.’ Mr. Bogard began to apply his hands to Ms. [redacted’s] breasts. Ms. [redacted] reports that at this point, she ‘froze.’

“Mr. Bogard then asked Ms. [redacted] to take off her pants. Ms. [redacted] admits that she complied. Mr. Bogard then asked Ms. [redacted] to crawl into the back seat, an act which was facilitated because her seat back was now lying flat. Again, she complied. The two then had sexual intercourse.”

Bogard told investigators that he has no recollection of the accuser "saying 'no' at any time while they were in the car."

After this encounter, Bogard’s accuser entered into a regular sexual relationship with him. She revealed that during the relationship she was sent a new employment contract with a non-disclosure agreement. When she asked about it, investigators noted: “Mr. Bogard told her ‘if you don’t sign this contract, you don’t work here.’”

Investigators found that despite the nature of the case, the failure to adequately investigate it and the substantial passage of time since it happened, a jury would have likely found that Bogard had sex with the former junior staffer against her will.

“There can be no doubt that given the extreme power imbalance between the two, as well as the ‘don’t say no’ culture which permeated the New York Church at that time, there was ample opportunity for Mr. Bogard to take advantage of a systemic inability for Ms. [redacted] to have meaningfully consented at the time in question,” the report noted. “Without discounting the strength of a prosecution case due to the passage of time, it is likely that a jury, evaluating the interplay, would have found that Mr. Bogard acted without obtaining (or, under the circumstances, having any reasonable expectation of being able to obtain) actual consent by Ms. [redacted].”

Along with the former junior staffer and Bogard, the following individuals were interviewed as part of the internal investigation: Jenna Babbitt, a former Hillsong NYC congregant; Shannon Kelly, a former creative director at Hillsong NYC; Amanda and Robert Fergusson, a husband and wife team of Bible teachers and key leaders of Hillsong Church; Jess Bogard, wife of Reed Bogard; Lauren Brooks (sic), a former creative producer at Hillsong NYC; Tolu Badders, chief operating officer and executive pastor at Hillsong Church NYC; Kane Keatinge, Hillsong NYC staff pastor; Carl Lentz, former Hillsong NYC lead pastor who was fired in November 2020 over “leadership issues” and moral failures, including being unfaithful to his wife; Laura Lentz and Ben Houston.

The investigators further explained that it was concerning that Hillsong Church never considered the power imbalance between the two — Bogard and his accuser — once they were informed about the relationship.

“The fact that no Church leader appears to have even considered this issue is a cause for concern," investigators said. "An additional cause for concern is that even within the parameters of the sexual relationship between them, it appears that the sexual activities between the two frequently suggest that they were designed to reinforce the power imbalance between them.” 

"In recounting various liaisons, Ms. [redacted] consistently talks about how ‘Reed wanted to have sex, so we had sex,’ and similar comments, always indicating that Mr. Bogard was the initiator.

“Mr. Bogard even summoned Ms. [redacted] to his own apartment on his last day in New York for sex, even though the building where he lived was occupied by most of the senior leaders of the New York church and Ms. [redacted] would be exposed to coming and going there.”

Investigators noted that Bogard’s decision to force his accuser into signing an NDA was also another example of his abuse of power.

“No compelling legitimate reason was given by Mr. Bogard for why this demand was made in the middle of the affair. And this is yet another example of the abuse of power that seems to have permeated the entire relationship,” they said.

Bogard was also painted as a leader at Hillsong NYC who “had a reputation for aggression, verbal abuse and unreasonable demands,” which witnesses called “UnChristian.” Investigators said in their interview with him, “Mr. Bogard did present as aggressive.”

Kelly told investigators that even if Bogard did not physically force himself on his accuser she did not have the ability to say no.

“Shannon stated that Mr. Bogard had an enormous amount of power and that Mr. Bogard was someone that if you said no to, it would be used against you in a lot of different ways. She stated people did not say no to Mr. Bogard,” investigators said.

“Shannon stated that from the way Ms. [redacted] spoke about the relationship with Mr. Bogard, it was something Mr. Bogard put pressure on Ms. [redacted] to do,” investigators added. “Shannon observed that from her point of view, of all the people Mr. Bogard could have chosen, Ms. [redacted] was probably the most vulnerable.”

==========================================================================================



Hillsong Atlanta pastor announces resignation in wake of

scandals surrounding global church

By Leah MarieAnn Klett, 
Assistant Editor Twitter| 
Wednesday, March 23, 2022

Sam and Toni Collier. | Hillsong

Sam Collier, the first-ever African American lead pastor of a Hillsong church, has announced he is stepping down from his position as a slew of scandals continue to surround the church and its founder, Brian Houston. 

Collier, who with his wife, Toni, led the Atlanta, Georgia-based branch of Hillsong, announced his departure from the church on Wednesday afternoon.

“My greatest reason for stepping down as Pastor of Hillsong Atlanta is probably not a secret to any of you. With all of the documentaries, scandals, articles, accusations and the church’s subsequent management of these attacks it’s become too difficult to lead and grow a young Church in this environment,” Collier, who is also an author, adviser to the King family, and founder of A Greater Story Ministries, wrote on social media.

“I have no shame in admitting I cried like a baby moments after I informed the Hillsong global pastor of my departure."

Hillsong Atlanta was launched in October 2020 with the goal of reaching and influencing the world “by building a large Christ-centered, Bible-based church, changing mindsets and empowering people to lead and impact in every sphere of life,” Collier told The Christian Post at the time. 

He told CP the church aimed to be a “multicultural, spirit-filled and theologically astute church” — one that models unity in a desperately divided time in history. 

“We’ve kind of dropped the ball, historically, when it comes to unity,” he said, quoting Martin Luther King Jr., who once described 11 a.m. on Sunday mornings as "one of the most segregated hours in Christian America." 

“The world models how to come together better than the church does,” he lamented. “We want to change that. Hillsong Atlanta wants to provide a model for how to be unified. We want to have a ministry that is multicultural and unified so we can help people learn to live together for the sake of the Kingdom of God.”

Collier’s announcement came just hours after Hillsong revealed that Houston, who founded the church in 1983 with his wife, Bobbie, had resigned from his role as global senior pastor.

It was revealed that Houston, who had initially stepped down from the church's boards last September after he was charged with “concealing child sex offenses,” had violated the church’s pastoral code of conduct by entering the hotel room of an unidentified woman for 40 minutes while under the influence of alcohol and prescription drugs during the church’s annual conference in 2019.

“We understand there will be much emotion at this news, and we all share these feelings," Hillsong said in a statement Wednesday. "Irrespective of the circumstances around this, we can all agree that Brian and Bobbie have served God faithfully over many decades and that their ministry has resulted in millions of people across the world being impacted by the power, grace, and love of Jesus Christ."

But other high-profile sexual misconduct scandals have plagued the megachurch and its campuses amid the COVID-19 pandemic, including the 2020 firing of Carl Lentz, who led Hillsong Church in New York City, over “leadership issues” and moral failures, including being unfaithful to his wife.

In April 2021, former Hillsong Dallas Lead Pastor Reed Bogard and his wife, Jess, abruptly resigned from their positions. It was revealed that the two were under investigation for “leadership failures,” resulting in the closure of that campus.


Another Hillsong resignation is that of Darnell Barrett, the former creative director of Hillsong Church Montclair in New Jersey. He was accused of sending explicit photos to a Hillsong volunteer.



Meanwhile, on Thursday, Discovery Plus will premiere a three-episode docuseries titled “Hillsong: A Megachurch Exposed” that purports to highlight how the Australia-based global Evangelical church network has toed the “fine line between cult and culture.”

Prior to pastoring Hillsong Atlanta, Collier, who wrote the 2020 book, A Greater Story, served at Atlanta-based North Point Community Church, led by Pastor Andy Stanley

In his statement Wednesday, Collier said he truly loves the Hillsong family and believes “they will get through this storm and come out better than they were before.”

He revealed that this coming Sunday will mark his final service at Hillsong Atlanta, where he plans to share more information about a new church he’s launching on Easter Sunday.

“I have appreciated the Hillsong family and want to thank the Houstons for the love they have shown Toni and me,” he wrote.