Everyday thousands of children are being sexually abused. You can stop the abuse of at least one child by simply praying. You can possibly stop the abuse of thousands of children by forwarding the link in First Time Visitor? by email, Twitter or Facebook to every Christian you know. Save a child or lots of children!!!! Do Something, please!

3:15 PM prayer in brief:
Pray for God to stop 1 child from being molested today.
Pray for God to stop 1 child molestation happening now.
Pray for God to rescue 1 child from sexual slavery.
Pray for God to save 1 girl from genital circumcision.
Pray for God to stop 1 girl from becoming a child-bride.
If you have the faith pray for 100 children rather than one.
Give Thanks. There is more to this prayer here

Please note: All my writings and comments appear in bold italics in this colour

Showing posts sorted by relevance for query Cashel. Sort by date Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by relevance for query Cashel. Sort by date Show all posts

Wednesday, 30 December 2020

This Week's Catholic Pervs and Paedos List > 2021 Could be a Really Bad Year for the Catholic Church

..
Approval of Catholic Church in Poland dips to nearly 30yr low amid pedophilia scandal & protests over new abortion restrictions
20 Dec 2020 11:42

FILE PHOTO:
A Catholic priest performs a ceremony in Nidek, Poland. April 2020.
© Reuters / Agencja Gazeta / Jakub Porzycki

Public opinion of the Catholic Church in Poland is the lowest it has been since the early 1990s, a new poll shows. The clergy’s reputation was damaged by recent sexual abuse allegations and protests over restrictive abortion laws.

The results of the CBOS poll published by Polish media earlier this week showed that 47 percent had a negative view of the activities of the Catholic Church in the country, compared to just 41 percent who viewed the Church’s activities favorably. The survey was conducted between November 30 and December 10, and included 1,010 people.

This is the lowest approval rating the Church has had since 1993. Investigative website OKO.press reported that people were dismayed by its “excessive” role in social and political life that year – a strict anti-abortion law took effect that January and Warsaw signed a treaty with the Vatican several months later. The situation now seems to have repeated itself, as many Poles are angered by new restrictions on abortion and dismayed that the clergy have been embroiled in sex abuse scandals. 

The Catholic Church traditionally plays an important role in Poland, especially compared to fellow EU nations. The bishops and the Catholic media are considered one of the bedrocks of the support of the ruling conservative Law and Justice (PiS) party.

However, the Church’s approval rating has been steadily declining in recent years. Its positive perception dropped below 50 percent in May 2019, which coincided with the premiere of a documentary about the sexual abuse of young boys by the Polish clergy. The film caused an uproar, receiving more than 20 million views on YouTube in just eight days.

The scandal was followed by the resignation of Edward Janiak, a bishop at the Roman Catholic Diocese of Kalisz, who was accused of shielding the priests that were implicated in abusing children.   

The Church’s reputation took another dent in October, when the country’s highest court removed severe fetus deformities from the already short list of reasons for which a woman is legally permitted to seek an abortion. The ruling immediately sparked widespread protests across the country.

Some senior priests have spoken dismissively about the women at the frontline of the protest rallies. Marek Jedraszewski, the influential Archbishop of Krakow, gave a sermon this week, blasting the “Julki” – a slur used for a young female left-wing activists – who wanted to become “an encore to the man.” The archbishop said women attending rallies should pay attention to how they dress and speak, and ask themselves “by what right do they deviate from the model of femininity, the highest example of which was given to us by the Holy Mother.”

The fierce protests ultimately forced the government to miss the deadline for the certification of the court ruling, which has indefinitely delayed the implementation of the new abortion restrictions.




Edmonton priest released from duties after discovery of
past sexual assault allegation
By Slav Kornik  Global News
Posted December 26, 2020 1:53 pm

The Catholic Archdiocese of Edmonton offices, Saturday, Dec. 26, 2020. Eric Beck, Global News

The Catholic Archdiocese of Edmonton has removed a local priest from his duties after learning of a previous sexual assault accusation.

The Archdiocese said Rev. Sylvio Lacar was removed from his role after it learned the Archdiocese of Los Angeles identified Lacar as the person whom a “credible accusation of sexual abuse of a minor” was brought forward against in the 1980s.

In a news release, the Archdiocese’s communications lead Andrew Ehrkamp said Lacar has denied the allegation and there was no criminal prosecution against him, but Lacar was included in a group civil settlement.

“The Catholic Archdiocese of Edmonton takes any allegation of abuse very seriously and acted swiftly upon learning of this allegation against Rev. Lacar by removing him from any public ministry while investigating,” Ehrkamp said.

St. Theresa’s Catholic Church in Edmonton, Saturday, Dec. 26, 2020. Eric Beck, Global News

According to the Archdiocese, Lacar is a retired priest who was regularly serving at St. Theresa’s Parish in Ma-Me-O Beach and occasionally at St. Theresa’s Parish in Mill Woods.

“The Archdiocese of Edmonton is committed to responding to reports of abuse by any of our clergy, staff or lay volunteers promptly, openly and in full co-operation with child welfare authorities and/or police,” Ehrkamp wrote in the statement.




I expected this to happen sooner or later. This must be terrifying for the church.

Insurance company sues Diocese of Brooklyn over sex abuse cases alleging it knew of prolific abuser
Sean Lahman
Rochester Democrat and Chronicle

An insurance company representing the Diocese of Brooklyn says it should not be responsible for paying settlements to victims who say they were sexually abused by the Diocese's priests.

In a federal lawsuit filed Monday, Arrowood Indemnity Company asks the court to rule that it should not be obligated to defend or indemnify the Diocese because of "allegations of the Diocese’s long-standing specific knowledge of individual instances of  abuse and its decades-long culture of coverup."

Arrowood also alleges that the Diocese has failed to provide copies of internal documents that would shed light on what it knew about allegations of abuse and what steps it took in response.

"The information the Diocese has provided... is inappropriately redacted, contains large chronological gaps, and is missing numerous pages without explanation," court papers said. 

The suit also says that while the diocese provided documents in response to a subpoena from the state's Attorney General, Arrowood's repeated requests for copies of those documents have gone unanswered. 

Nearly 500 lawsuits have been filed against the Diocese of Brooklyn alleging sexual abuse of minors under New York's Child Victims Act. 

That legislation, adopted in early 2019, carved out a one-year window during which suits can be brought by people who allege they were sexually abused when they were young. The special filing period was later extended by a full year, allowing claims to be filed in state court under the CVA statute until Aug. 14, 2021.

The Diocese of Brooklyn encompasses the counties of Brooklyn and Queens in the New York City area. An audit of the diocese finances in 2017 reported that its total cash and other assets was just under $44 million.

Arrowood's complaint names the Diocese of Brooklyn as a defendant along with more than 30 parish churches and diocesan schools. It also names former priest Romano J. Ferraro (5th story on link), a prolific abuser named in more than a dozen pending suits who is currently serving a life sentence in a Massachusetts prison.

Suit alleges diocese knew of abuser
Ferraro's history of abuse and the church's response are at the center of Arrowood's suit. In court papers, the insurer argues that the Diocese was aware of Ferraro's "sexual proclivities" as early as the 1950s, before he was ordained as a priest.

Court papers allege that during the 1960s, Ferraro repeatedly assaulted boys at parishes where he served, and each time the Diocese was made aware of the priest's misconduct, he was simply transferred to another Brooklyn parish. 

Ferraro was assigned to the US Navy as a chaplain in 1968, but was dishonorably discharged two years later based on an allegation of child sexual abuse, according to court papers. He returned to Brooklyn in 1971 where he is accused of continuing to abuse boys as he moved from parish to parish for the next 20 years.

In 2004, Ferraro was convicted and sentenced to life in prison for repeatedly raping a boy from 1973-80 in Billerica, Massachusetts starting when the boy was age 7. At trial, Ferraro admitted that he was a pedophile who had abused perhaps dozens of boys.

Citing information contained in the lawsuits against Ferraro, Arrowood says that church leaders knew that priests serving in the Diocese of Brooklyn "were grooming and sexually molesting children with whom the priests would have contact in their ministry and pastoral functions.”   

In its cause of action, Arrowood said the Diocese "engaged in a pattern of continuously reassigning and transferring Ferraro on at least nineteen (19) occasions despite knowledge that he was a pedophile."

It also claims that the Diocese "cultivated a culture of opportunity for Ferraro to sexually abuse children" and "failed to investigate prior allegations of sexual abuse of children by Ferraro, and failed to report the abuse to the authorities."

Arrowood's lawsuit also chronicles three other priests who have been credibly accused of abuse, and allegations that the Diocese moved them from parish to parish knowing they were likely to prey other victims.

Former priests Thomas O’Rourke,  Vincent Sforza, and James Sickler are the subject of at least 14 CVA lawsuits.

Arrowood argues that it has no obligation to defend and/or indemnify the Diocese "because the abuse that is the subject of those Actions was known by the Diocese ... to be certain or substantially certain to occur; the alleged injury from the abuse was expected or intended; and was otherwise not fortuitous."

A similar suit was filed in July by the insurance underwriter Lloyd's of London against the Archdiocese of Indianapolis for failing to disclose allegations of sexual abuse when it sought liability insurance, the Indianapolis Star reported.




Damning decision

Mount Cashel victims hope the Supreme Court of Canada holds the Roman Catholic Church responsible for years of child abuse they suffered at the orphanage in St. John's, Newfoundland, decades ago
By Ryan Cooke
CBC News, December 28, 2020

John Doe No. 26 places two weathered hands on his dining room table, smoothing out creases in a holiday tablecloth as he talks about the monsters of a Christmas past.

Dec. 25, 1955, was the day he put a stop to the abuse he suffered inside the hallowed walls of the Mount Cashel Orphanage in St. John’s.

For seven years, sadists in black robes and white collars desecrated so much that was innocent in the child. The abuse was physical, sexual and psychological.

“The punishment was not to correct the behaviour,” he said. “The punishment was satisfaction to the people who were applying the punishment. You were beaten with straps, with sticks, with fists, whatever. It made no difference and there’s no recourse to anyone.”

When he was big enough to fight back and angry enough to take no more, he used those rough hands to crack a chair over the skull of a man later sentenced as the worst of the worst — Brother Ronald Lasik.

Then just 15, John Doe No. 26 spent Christmas night with a shank crafted from a hayfork under his pillow to defend against any Christian Brother who came for retribution after the lights went out.

But nobody came. He was expelled the next day and left to fend for himself as an orphan in the dead of winter.

Now, he's hoping the Supreme Court of Canada will render a decision early in the new year, and affirm the Roman Catholic Church was responsible for what happened to him decades ago at the hands of a lay organization called the Christian Brothers of Ireland.

Him, and more than 100 other children.

There are publication bans protecting the identities of the victims — who are now elderly men — involved in the ongoing lawsuit. They are instead referred to by their John Doe numbers.

The Mount Cashel Orphanage opened on the outer edge of St. John's in 1898. It housed hundreds of boys until it closed in 1990 and was later demolished. (The Canadian Press)

This legal battle over responsibility at Mount Cashel has been ongoing since the late 1990s.

The Archdiocese of St. John’s claims no ownership over the orphanage, and no affiliation with the brothers who worked there. A Supreme Court of Newfoundland and Labrador judge sided with the church in 2018, but three appellate judges in the province sided with the victims in July 2020, ruling the Catholic Church was liable for damages because of its close relationship with the Christian Brothers.

Canada’s top court will soon decide whether to hear one last appeal or put the case to bed and leave the Catholic Church to pay for the sins of the brothers who ran the orphanage and school.

The case involves four plaintiffs — one of whom is dead, while the other three are in their 80s — who were residents at the orphanage in the 1950s.

Mount Cashel came to national prominence with a judicial inquiry that concluded in 1990 about abuse at the orphanage in the mid-1970s, and a deal the government made to effectively expel two sexually abusing brothers in return for no criminal charges. The inquiry was triggered at the same time as a new criminal investigation, which resulted in a series of criminal trials.

Those cases also opened up older instances of sexual and physical abuse at Mount Cashel, dating back decades. The case heading to the Supreme Court of Canada includes those older cases.

The consequences of a win for those four men would go far beyond themselves. There are dozens of others who could file lawsuits in Newfoundland and Labrador against the Archdiocese of St. John’s to pay the bills that the Christian Brothers left outstanding when the organization went bankrupt in 2012.

It’s a decision that could shape the future of the church in a city that was once a Catholic stronghold.

It's being watched by the church from St. John's to the Vatican, and by lawyers around the globe looking to prove the Roman Catholic hierarchy is liable in similar situations.

The boys

John Doe No. 26 came from a large family on Bell Island where God was at the centre of everything.

His father returned from the Second World War overseas on a compassionate discharge to care for his ailing wife. When she died in 1947, he couldn't shake her loss. Before long, he couldn't shake his addiction, either.

“A change came over my father. He lost everything. His whole world was my mother,” John Doe No. 26 said. “And he began to drink.”

After about a year, all five sons were taken from the home. The four older boys — ages five, eight, nine and 10 — were placed in Mount Cashel. The youngest son joined them a year later.

“From the time we got in there, until the time we got out, there was an atmosphere of fear and foreboding,” he said. “Everything was a physical beating for any infraction or perceived infraction.”

Sometimes it was a punch in the head. Other times, the brothers would lift a child up by the belt, stretching their pants tight across their buttocks and whip them with a swatch of leather.

The abuse was constant and unforgiving.

It was endured by countless other children, including one who now goes by John Doe No. 50 in court documents.

Seven hours skating up and down a frozen pond on a crisp winter’s day is the last happy memory John Doe No. 50 has before his childhood was fractured.

His adolescence was split in two acts — before the orphanage and after the orphanage.

Now 80, Mount Cashel lingers in his mind and looms over his life as a chasm where innocence plunged into nightmares.

He was a 12-year-old boy then, skating away from the fresh grief of his mother’s death. His uncle pulled up alongside the ice and ended the world as he knew it with one sentence.

“We’re taking you to the orphanage.”

He and his two younger brothers were uprooted from their rural life in St. Lawrence, N.L., and taken about 300 kilometres by boat to St. John’s. With their mother gone and their father dealing with the amputation of both his legs, the boys became wards of the Christian Brothers at Mount Cashel.

“I think my father just thought he was doing what was best for us,” John Doe No. 50 says today, almost 70 years later, from his home in St. John’s.

His father, like many poor and suffering parents who sent their sons to the orphanage, could never have known what was happening. And when he was told, John Doe No. 50 said his father refused to believe it.

The abuse

The beatings started almost immediately.

His voice shakes today as he recalls the constant threats and the psychological torture he faced on a regular basis.

There was one instance where a brother beat him with a stick after a sports practice. The brother cut him across the knee so badly the child had to go to hospital for stitches.

“He said ‘Remember, don’t tell the truth.’ So I said ‘OK.’ I wasn’t OK, but I knew what he had in mind,” he said, choking back tears. “That was something I’ll always remember.”

Shower time was a particularly anxious occasion in the orphanage. Hot water was in short supply with so many boys living in one place. As John Doe No. 50 tried to quickly splash water over himself and get out, Brother Ronald Lasik watched.

Lasik towered over children like a giant, the largest of the brothers at the time. His victims said he possessed a maniacal temper and an unpredictable malice.

He ordered the boy back into the shower and told him to lather up. He was naked, cold and had no escape from the inevitable abuse to follow.

Tears well in his eyes and his voice falters as he remembers the story today.

“He took a strap and laced me. I’m thinking, hey, there’s nothing you can do. You can’t defend yourself. The first thing they’d do is kick you out. And you had enough common sense to know, where are you going to go? If they kick you out, you’re finished. And I had two younger brothers that I was looking after pretty good.”

Even with the rampant physical torture throughout the school, most kids didn't know the full picture of what was going on at night.

John Doe No. 26 found out in Grade 7. He was repeatedly sexually assaulted by Brother J.E. Murphy, a man who would later serve 20 months house arrest for the crimes he committed at Mount Cashel.

As time went on, two other men began sexually abusing him as well — including Frank Clancy, an electrician who did work at the orphanage.

The children didn't know anyone other than their own self was being abused. They felt isolated. And yet it was so pervasive among the adults in the institution that John Doe No. 26 discovered even the electrician knew it was a haven for child abusers.

Years dragged by and John Doe No. 26 got bigger. He earned a reputation as a tough guy, but it was only a defence mechanism. On the inside, he was sensitive and lonely.

Some brothers had a habit of pitting boys against each other. John Doe No. 26 would later testify that Brother Murphy took it too far one night. He said Murphy ordered a pair of children to snatch up a stray dog he took care of and to throw it out the top floor window.

They did as they were told.

That was the last time Murphy would do anything to hurt John Doe No. 26 — physically, sexually or otherwise. "I was so enraged. I told him what he was and this sort of thing," he said. "He didn't come after me. He did not come after me. And after that, everything stopped. He knew I had reached the point."

One other incident led to John Doe No. 26 reaching his breaking point.

It was Christmas Day, 1955, and a local organization sent a container of candy to the orphans at Mount Cashel.

Brother Lasik had John Doe No. 26 dole out the candy as younger kids lined up in front of him. He was excited to do a good deed at Christmas, but Lasik had other plans.

He pointed out a boy nearing the front of the line, and ordered John Doe No. 26 not to give the child any candy.

Lasik made him do it again, excluding another little boy in the line. And again. And again.

John Doe No. 26’s heart broke over and over as he told each little boy they couldn't have candy at Christmas.

"I was going through f--king agony," he says today.

After seven years of constant beatings, molestation and fear, he was broken.

Later that night, the boys went upstairs to watch a movie. Off to the side of the auditorium, John Doe No. 26 saw Lasik laying a beating on a close friend of his.

"I lost everything. I guess it must have been pushed on, encouraged by what went on downstairs. So I picked up a chair, I went over and I crowned him with it."

He pushed Lasik off his friend and called him a coward.

Lasik did nothing.

The two boys slept next to each other that night with a makeshift spear under a pillow, fully expecting Lasik or someone else to come for them in the middle of the night.

"They didn't come."

The next day, they were expelled from the orphanage.

Seven years of daily hell were finally over.

The reckoning

The orphanage was quiet from the outside.

It was known for its brass band and athletics. Its Christmas raffle was an annual hit, where people could win prizes like live chickens and feel good about giving money to children in need.

And then, in 1989, the benevolence of it all was blown to pieces.

John Doe No. 26 saw the news on TV — a public inquiry was being opened in relation to a coverup at Mount Cashel.

He'd done his best to live a normal life until that point. He had a university degree and a respected profession, and was a decorated coach.

His wife found him in the basement when she came home that day. "I completely went to pieces," he said. "I was uncontrollable. Finally I settled down enough to tell her what happened to me."

He sat down that night and wrote a deposition for the Hughes Inquiry, before anyone could even ask him to be involved. As the words flowed out onto the page, the flood of emotions was overwhelming. There was horror, but also comfort in knowing he wasn't an isolated case.

People began coming forward with allegations not just of abuse at Mount Cashel, but of an elaborate coverup involving police and social workers.

The Hughes Inquiry blew the lid off the entire scandal and proved that a Royal Newfoundland Constabulary officer had interviewed 24 boys in 1975 about physical and sexual abuse at the orphanage. He'd even secured confessions of molestation from two Christian Brothers.

And then he was ordered by his superiors to destroy his report and write a second one, scrubbing from it all references to sexual abuse.

Out of the inquiry came criminal cases against several Christian Brothers, and the electrician Frank Clancy.

John Doe No. 50, who had also gone on to live a productive life with a loving family, did his part to help put Brother Lasik behind bars.

Lasik received the stiffest punishment of anyone — 11 years, of which he only served four and was deported back to the United States.

He died in February 2020. No obituary was posted online. He remained a registered sex offender in the State of New York until his death.

Civil court filings in Illinois allege Lasik also assaulted two boys at a high school in Chicago after his time at Mount Cashel.

The law

As the dust settled on the Hughes Inquiry and the criminal trials, the fight for compensation began.

Civil lawsuits helped solidify household names out of lawyers like former Newfoundland and Labrador premier Danny Williams, and longtime Member of Parliament Jack Harris.

But a case taken by a lesser-known litigator in St. John's would prove more challenging.

Geoff Budden never intended to take the case.

In 1997, he was approached by someone on behalf of a Mount Cashel victim from the 1950s who wanted to sue the brothers and the church. Knowing it was a tall order, Budden passed.

A while later, the person called back again and said nobody else would take the case. “So I did some research and thought that I did see a viable path forward and then I was retained by these guys," Budden said.

It started with one man, and eventually grew to 60 victims from the same era, including John Doe No. 26 and John Doe No. 50.

The case immediately became bogged down in complications. Mount Cashel was staffed with teachers from the Congregation of Christian Brothers of Ireland, but they were not incorporated in Canada at the time.

It was clear there was an American connection — most of the early brothers came from the United States — so Budden formed a partnership with an American lawyer and went after the Christian Brothers Institute in New York.

Years of back and forth ensued, with the institute claiming it had no jurisdiction over the brothers at Mount Cashel and therefore shouldn't be sued for their wrongdoings.

Then Budden's team found a document filed at a New Jersey courthouse where the Christian Brothers Institute was suing its insurance company for failing to cover child abuse claims it settled in that state. The document stated the opposite of what the institute had claimed in Newfoundland and Labrador, and clearly stated it was responsible for staffing at facilities outside New York.

The Christian Brothers Institute folded its hand, and the lawsuit proceeded.

But there was always a bigger target than the brothers.

The church

For 22 years, Budden and his group of lawyers and John Does have been trying to prove the Archdiocese of St. John's should pay for what happened at Mount Cashel.

Budden's team had two arguments. One, that the church knew about the abuse and did nothing, and two, that the church was in a position of liability through its close relationship with the Christian Brothers.

What the lawyers turned up on the first argument shook John Doe No. 26 to his core.

Budden's team presented evidence that at least seven children went to confession and told the chaplain at Mount Cashel about the physical and sexual abuse they were enduring.

They spoke up when John Doe No. 26 couldn't. “These kids stood up and I laud them continually and I always will for the stand they took, the courage they showed," he said.

Despite the compelling evidence of confessions, Justice Alphonsus Faour of the Supreme Court of Newfoundland and Labrador rejected this argument for several reasons.

There was insufficient evidence about what the chaplain did or didn't do with the information, and the judge also said it was unclear whether or not he understood what the boys were telling him.

"The testimony and statements provided indicate only seven disclosures out of potentially hundreds of confessions heard by the priest during the relevant period," Faour wrote. "Those disclosures may have either not been believed or may have been misunderstood by the confessor.”

John Doe No. 26 had been in and out of touch with his religious beliefs throughout his life. That line in the decision was the final blow.

“I was completely slayed. I could not find any reasonable explanation for that decision by the judge. I mean, if I’ve got to shoot seven people to show evidence that I have committed a murder — one is too many. But only seven? I lost all faith.”

Faour ruled against Budden's team on both arguments and sided with the church in his 2018 decision.

The surviving members of the original lawsuit were disappointed by the decision, but had not given up. They urged Budden to appeal it to the Court of Appeal of Newfoundland and Labrador.

On July 29, 2020, three judges with the appellate court sided with Budden's team on the issue of vicarious liability, and ordered the church to pay the outstanding damages to the victims or their estates.

“It’s beautiful. It’s powerful. It’s satisfying and it makes me stand a little taller," John Doe No. 26 said. "Somebody has come out and said the church is responsible.... Somebody else stood up for us.”

In September, the church decided to exhaust its final appeal. It asked the Supreme Court of Canada to hear the case.

The country's highest court hears about 13 per cent of the applications it receives each year.

A decision on whether or not it will hear the case is expected by early January.

The consequences

This decision could be the last of the major rulings on Mount Cashel. There will be nothing left to dispute about what happened and who is responsible.

If the court turns down the appeal, it could set off a new flood of litigation against the church. Budden estimates about 160 former Mount Cashel residents have been involved in lawsuits against the Christian Brothers. Most were never paid in full.

This decision would put the cheque in the church's hand.

South of the border, one lawyer is eagerly awaiting the outcome.

When it comes to suing the church, Mitchell Garabedian is regarded as a pioneer.

The Boston lawyer, famously played by Stanley Tucci in the Academy Award-winning best picture Spotlight, helped lift the lid off clergy abuse in the United States in the 1990s. He's represented 2,500 clients in clergy abuse cases around the world.

Garabedian believes the highest levels of the Catholic church are watching just as intently as he is, and for the same reasons. Vicarious liability is a relatively new area of law, and this case could set a road map for clergy abuse cases around the world.

“Every time you add a layer of an institution, it gets more difficult to prove that institution’s involvement in the case," Garabedian said. "So the Vatican is concerned this case will be a very strong example of multi-layered institutions within the Catholic Church being successfully sued.”

The Archbishop of St. John's declined an interview for this story, saying it would be inappropriate to speak before the case is finished.

Budden said the appeal court decision, if upheld by the Supreme Court of Canada, is significant not just for the church, but for any person or institution that works in child protection.

"Out of that comes laws that I think will make this a better country," he said. "I think anybody now who is involved in caring for children knows they not only have a moral duty to act a certain way, they have legal duties. And if they fail in those duties, guess what? They're facing some pretty heavy consequences."

Mount Cashel was demolished in 1999. The land is now the site of a strip mall with a supermarket. The proceeds from the land deal went to victims. 

John Doe No. 50 hopes he can soon walk away with a satisfactory ending after so many years of fighting.

For him, it's not the money. It's the acknowledgement of responsibility and hopefully an apology. "I think we're entitled to it," he said with a tear in his eye.

"There's a lot of our guys who have died. They never got to see anything happen. And to me, that's cruel. I only pray that I stay around long enough, not just for compensation, but to have this wiped from my mind, so I don't have to think about this anymore."

John Doe No. 26 doesn't expect an apology, and wouldn't believe it sincere after all the time and money the archdiocese exhausted fighting against them.

He's watched as the boys of Mount Cashel helped shape St. John's over the decades, for better and worse, sometimes wondering if they, too, suffered the same abuse as him.

Some became politicians, tradesmen, teachers.

Plenty of others became lost along the way, falling into drugs and alcohol and repeating the cycle of abuse.

A close friend of mine was one of those Mt Cashel survivors who got lost along the way. He was in his 50s when a Christian prison ministry completely changed his life.

“The highway of life is strewn with the wrecked bodies and minds of Mount Cashel orphans," he said. "I tell you. I know so many. I know so, so many. My God.”




Sunday, 27 November 2022

This Week's Catholic Pervs and Paedos List > Mount Cashel's horrific legacy spread to Vancouver

..

Who let the wolves in?


Mount Cashel survivors horrified as more than 60 Vancouver men come forward

with allegations against the teachers who abused them

By Ryan Cooke
CBC News
Nov. 24, 2022

Warning: This story contains details of sexual abuse and suicide


Bob Connors is waiting for a reckoning.

At 59 years of age, he spends many nights trapped in the orphanage where he grew up. The walls of his suburban home transform into a darkened dormitory, and he’s haunted by the men who crept from one bed to the next.

His dreams reflect the terror he experienced as a little boy at the hands of the Christian Brothers at Mount Cashel Orphanage in St. John’s, Newfoundland. His abusers may have disappeared from the dormitories, but Connors has spent his entire life fighting off their forceful hands in the dark.

“The scars and the bad memories — that’ll stay with me for the rest of my life,” he said in a rare interview from his home near Kitchener, Ont.

Newfoundland and Labrador has spent decades trying to quantify the horrors at Mount Cashel. Hundreds abused. More than a dozen men charged. Tens of millions paid out in settlements.

Bob Connors chooses to measure Mount Cashel by its death toll — how many young men couldn’t stand the nightmares anymore?

It’s a count that includes his two younger brothers, Greg and Darrin, whom he tried so hard to protect.

“There was no other way out for them and eventually they took their lives,” Connors said. “And it all had to do with what happened in Mount Cashel.”

Connors holds a devastating place in Newfoundland and Labrador’s history: he was one of the boys who went to police in 1975 and told them children were being abused at the orphanage. His statement, along with about 23 others, were buried in a coverup that saw six Christian Brothers sent away and the investigation called off without charges.

The Catholic Church's penchant for molesting boys could have been 'outed' more than 25 years before it was had St John's had something equivalent to Boston Globe's Spotlight. 

Connors is only now learning what happened after the coverup, as new allegations emerge in a Vancouver courtroom, and another city struggles to quantify allegations of systemic, institutional abuse by the very same men who were removed from Mount Cashel.

Connors is waiting for a reckoning — but not for the people who abused him or those who covered it up. Instead, he’s waiting for the day it all catches up with him and the gates he’s built around his suburban life come crashing down.
.
Colin Wilson says his experience at Vancouver College left him with trauma he’s struggled with for decades.
(Ben Nelms/CBC)

II. ‘I never told my parents’


Colin Wilson remembers the rain hitting the roof of the van as he sat in silence, his teacher gripping the wheel as they drove farther from the school.

It was a cold evening in December 1984. Some kids at Vancouver College were helping out with the annual Christmas tree sale in the parking lot, but Wilson and three other boys were inside.

Wilson remembers the four Grade 9 boys sitting outside Joseph Burke’s office at the back of the cafeteria. Burke, a math teacher, called them in one at a time, checking over their schoolwork. It was late by the time Burke called for him, Wilson said, and he could tell he was angry.

Wilson wasn’t always afraid of his math teacher. He was an athletic student, and Burke was the coach of the football team. In a school filled with more “militant” Christian Brothers, Wilson said he trusted Burke and found they had things in common.

“He started to kind of take me under his wing with a few other kids and have us after school,” Wilson said. “Check up on our homework and make sure that we were being good students.”

Joseph Burke, left, became the head coach of the Vancouver College Fighting Irish football team after a stint across town at St. Thomas More Collegiate. A former standout football player himself, he returned to teach and coach in the 1980s. (St. Thomas More Collegiate yearbook)

Burke was collegial in the corridors and on the football field, Wilson said, but he began to show a different side of himself as the after-school sessions progressed. There were days where Burke would be looking for problems, Wilson said, and he was quick to anger.

Wilson said there were three stages to Burke’s discipline: spanking over the pants with the palm of his hand, spanking with a piece of wood about as thick as a hockey stick, and a bare-bottom spanking.

Burke has not responded to CBC’s requests for comment on the allegations in this story. Wilson’s allegations have yet to be tested in court.

On this particular December evening, Wilson said Burke told him they were going straight to Stage 3 — but it was too late to stay at the school.

Wilson said Burke took him along as he locked up, and then told him to get in his van. He said they sat in silence as Burke drove south to the Marpole neighbourhood, stopping outside his apartment and telling the 13-year-old boy to go inside.

Wilson recounts the story without hesitation.

“He then asked me to drop my pants, which I did, and I stood there in my underwear, and he said, ‘All of it.’ At this point I’m crying, you know, snot and everything coming out of my nose, and he put me across his lap and hit me.”

Wilson said Burke hit his bare bottom about 10 times while they were alone in his apartment, then told him to get dressed. He remembers sobbing as they got back in the van, and drove to a bus stop.

“I never told my parents.”

Colin Wilson was in eighth grade when he transferred to Vancouver College, a private Catholic school.
He says his life was turned upside down a year later when he was abused by a teacher.
(Submitted by Colin Wilson)


Wilson’s parents were devout Catholics, and Vancouver College was considered an elite private school for Catholic boys. It was run by the Christian Brothers of Ireland in Canada, who operated institutions across the country and were revered by the communities they served.

The brothers were something less than priests, but their charitable work and close ties with the Catholic Church made them respected figures. Wilson said his parents would have never believed they could allow something so heinous to happen.

The bishops who arranged the transfer of these perverts should have been sent to prison for enabling the destruction of so many children's lives. Many of the survivors of Mount Cashel ended up in prison. Many of them got into hard drugs to numb the pain. Terrible things happen when you are on hard drugs.

There is so much more to this disturbing story at CBC.




Friday, 10 March 2023

This Week's Catholic Pervs and Paedos List > Offaly Priest's Incredible Evil; Christian Brothers sued for sending Mt Cashel paedophile priests/teachers to Vancouver

..

Former Offaly priest who abused woman as he brought her 

to counselling avoids jail


He later asked her for forgiveness before assaulting her again

Fiona Ferguson
Sunday World
Today at 10:35

A former Offaly priest who sexually abused a young woman as he drove her to the Rape Crisis Centre for counselling has avoided a jail term as he is the sole carer for his elderly sister.

Joe Dunne (81) indecently assaulted the previously abused young woman on a number of occasions after befriending her in hospital. He later asked her for forgiveness before assaulting her again.

The woman outlined how meeting Dunne when she was a young woman in a highly vulnerable situation had started “34 years of hell.” She said she thought she would be safe as he was a priest.

Dunne of Ballycrystal, Geashill, Co Offaly pleaded guilty at the Central Criminal Court to five counts of indecent assault of the woman in 1989. He has no previous convictions.

The court heard the case had come to light as a result of a separate investigation in 2019 when gardai came across letters the injured party had written to her bishop about Dunne years earlier.

Gardai then approached the woman and she disclosed to them what had occurred.

Mr Justice McDermott said the circumstances of the case were extremely aggravating and noted Dunne had got himself into a position where he could sexually assault an abused woman. “That’s shocking, said the judge.

He said it was clear from the nature of the assaults that they were carried out on a young woman in a most vulnerable position and who Dunne knew to be in vulnerable position after she turned to him for support at difficult time.

He said he was obliged to take Dunne’s guilty plea into account but said it appeared from some material presented to court that he does not have full appreciation of the damage done.

The judge also took into account Dunne’s age and his health issues in setting a sentence of four years imprisonment.

He said he also had to take into account the effect imprisoning Dunne would have on his 94-year-old sister for whom Dunne is the sole carer. He said the report before in him in that regard was “stark.” He said the woman would be in very serious circumstances if deprived of his support.

He said the court was faced with a dilemma and he took the “unusual and exceptional step” of suspending the entire sentence because of the disproportionate effect it would have on Dunne's sister.

The judge said this was not something easily done on his part but said it seemed to him it would involve a significant penalty on a third party if Dunne served the sentence.

Mr Justice McDermott suspended the entirety of the four year sentence on strict conditions including that Dunne attend with the Probation Service and undertake offence focused work.

Garda Darren Hughes told Conor Devally SC, prosecuting, that the woman had previously been abused by another person and spent some time in hospital as she found it difficult to get over. Dunne had befriended her in the hospital while aware she was highly vulnerable.

She was due to attend counselling which was difficult for her to access due to her rural location and Dunne offered to drive her to the Rape Crisis Centre. During several trips to the Rape Crisis Centre, Dunne indecently assaulted the young woman.

The young woman was shocked and thought no one would believe this behaviour of a priest so found it hard to reveal what was happening to her. She eventually prevailed on her family to keep Dunne away and made alternative arrangements.

Dunne approached the young woman and sought her forgiveness. She felt she had no choice but to forgive him and that it would be a sin not to do so. He prevailed on her to take a trip with him and again assaulted her in the car.

Dunne emigrated for some time and was in ministry in Scotland but the woman observed on his return that he was filling in to say masses and funerals so at this stage she wrote to her bishop.

The court heard “little or nothing” was done at that stage to make Dunne “amenable to the law.”

Dunne was arrested and interviewed during the later investigation after her letters came to light in 2019.

Dunne, who has been removed from ministry, made limited admissions at that stage, but entered a guilty plea to the indecent assaults prior to a trial date.

In her victim impact statement she said meeting Dunne had started 34 years of hell. She said she had been very low and told him what was wrong. He then insisted on bringing her to counselling but used these trips to abuse her. She said she had felt she would be safe with him as he was a priest.

She outlined the devastating effects the abuse has had on her life in relation to relationships, her mental health and employment. She feels she will grow old on her own as she can not trust anyone.

“I hope he will understand how he destroyed me,” she told the court in her statement.

Joe Dunne took the stand in court and told the woman he was very sorry for “anything I did to you”. He agreed with his defence counsel that his actions had been a great breach of trust.

The court heard Dunne has a number of medical issues and is on a range of different medications. He is hard of hearing and has mobility difficulties. Dunne told the court his sister, who is in her 90s and has her own medical difficulties, is fully dependent on him.

Defence counsel said Dunne had acknowledged the breach of trust he committed and expressed remorse, as well as apologising publicly.

Sure, he did that before and then took her right out and sexually assaulted her again.

He said Dunne was a man of no previous convictions who has led a good life and not come to any further garda attention. He asked the court to take his client's good character in the intervening years into account.

He said that Dunne’s sister was dependent on him and it would lead to hardship for her if Dunne was incarcerated. He handed up a number of medical reports and letters in this regard.

What an unbelievable creep! Pretending to be a man of God! He will soon stand before Jesus and we will see if He thinks Dunne was a man of God.




How a class-action in B.C. is tied to one of the biggest

sex-abuse scandals in Canadian history


Claim alleges 6 abusers were transferred from notorious St. John's orphanage

to Catholic schools in Vancouver-area


CBC News · 
Posted: Mar 10, 2023 4:00 AM PST | Last Updated: March 10

The Mount Cashel Orphanage in St. John's, pictured in 1989. (Andrew Vaughan/The Canadian Press)


A lawsuit alleging nearly four decades of systemic abuse at two Catholic schools in B.C. has been certified by the courts as a class action, a move lawyers say could clear the way for as many as 65 potential survivors to seek compensation against the Catholic order accused of shuffling the abusers into their schools.

The original claim said the Christian Brothers of Ireland knowingly transferred abusive clergymen from a notorious orphanage in Newfoundland to Vancouver College and St. Thomas More Collegiate, where they went on to sexually and physically abuse more children from 1976 to 2013.

In a decision Wednesday, a B.C. Supreme Court justice found a class action would be the best way to move the case forward — rather than having each alleged victim file their own independent lawsuit.

"The decision creates a single lawsuit that can litigate the common issues between all of those people," said lawyer Reidar Mogerman, who represents the alleged victims.

"This is a really important step."

What happened at the Mount Cashel Orphanage?


The lawsuit links back to the Mount Cashel Orphanage in St. John's, where hundreds of vulnerable children were abused (and sexually abused) for decades by "cruel and sadistic" men charged with their care. Multiple criminal investigations led to a number of convictions.

A public inquiry found senior public servants, church officials, police brass and politicians helped cover up the crimes — cementing the case as one of the largest sex abuse scandals in Canadian history.

This was also the first big exposure of paedophilia in the Catholic priesthood, predating Boston's Spotlight revelations by several years.

Who are the Christian Brothers?


The Christian Brothers of Ireland is a religious community headquartered in Rome. The organization expanded into Canada in the early 1800s.

The order ran hundreds of schools around the world, including the Mount Cashel orphanage before its closure in 1990.

It founded Vancouver College, and St. Thomas More Collegiate in neighbouring Burnaby.

In other words, they did a lot of good things before the lust of the flesh took over the priesthood and lay workers. The Christian Brothers should be forced to change their name, or dissolve completely.

Vancouver College pictured on Thursday. (Ben Nelms/CBC)


Which abuses are alleged to have happened in B.C.?


The B.C.-based claim said the Christian Brothers sent six members from Mount Cashel to the Vancouver-area schools between 1976 and 1983.

All six were later convicted of sexually or physically abusing orphans at the Newfoundland facility, with two of them having admitted abuse before they were sent west.

A judge in 2004 found the Catholic order struck a deal with investigators in 1975: the members in question wouldn't face criminal charges for their actions at Mount Cashel in exchange for them leaving the province and seeking treatment.

The lead plaintiff in B.C., Darren Liptrot, claims one of the brothers, Edward English, sexually abused him from 1981 to 1983 while he was a student at Vancouver College in grades 9 and 10.

He said he tried to report the abuse to his vice-principal but was ignored.

None of the allegations has been proven in court and no statements of defence have been filed.

Edward English confessed to police in St. John's in 1975 about abusing boys at Mount Cashel Orphanage. Officials in the justice system covered it up, an inquiry later found, and English was allowed to leave the province. He's now accused of the same acts in B.C. in the 1980s. (CBC)


Why was the class-action certified in B.C.?


Since Liptrot filed his claim, his lawyers told the court more than 65 men have come forward claiming they were abused at the Vancouver-area schools by the clergymen sent from Mount Cashel.

Liptrot's lawyer argued a class-action makes it easier for potential victims to seek justice. They said it should be open to those who claim they were abused at any period between 1976 and 2013, when the last of the six men retired.

"There's really significant barriers to victims coming forward and so a class action like this breaks those barriers down," said Mogerman, the plaintiffs' lawyer.

St. Thomas More Collegiate in Burnaby, B.C., pictured on Thursday. (Ben Nelms/CBC)


The defence argued individual trials would be preferred but the judge said lawyers "provided no useful, concrete examples of their alternative model as preferable for systemic abuse cases like this one."

Defence lawyers also argued the class period of 1976 to 2013 would be too long, but the judge disagreed.

The six men sent to B.C. and later convicted of physical or sexual abuse were Joseph Burke, David Burton, Edward English, Edward French, Douglas Kenny and Kevin Short. 

The lawsuit says the former students have suffered significant damage including pain and suffering, psychological injuries, addiction issues, the inability to have normal and healthy sexual development and spiritual trauma including loss of faith.

The lawsuit says the plaintiffs want a declaration that they were abused and the defendants are liable for that abuse; an award for damages for negligence; past and future costs of health care; and punitive and aggravated damages.

With files from The Canadian Press

Is it too late to prosecute those responsible for sending the perverts west?



Thursday, 22 September 2022

This Week's Catholic Pervs and Paedos List > Diocese reinstating Priests accused of CSA; Judge halts payments to predator priests; Mount Cashel Predators Flew West

..

With little explanation, Buffalo diocese has reinstated 17 priests

accused of sexual abuse

Jay Tokasz 
Buffalo News
Sep 6, 2022

Buffalo Diocese Bishop Michael Fisher at Mass at St. Joseph Cathedral in Buffalo on Feb. 6, 2022.


Seventeen of the 29 Buffalo Diocese priests put on administrative leave since 2018 due to a sex abuse allegation involving a minor were later allowed to resume their priestly activities.

The diocese publicized the priests’ returns to ministry by stating that a review board had examined the claims and found them to be “not substantiated.”

Diocese officials maintain that the review process is rigorous, independent and designed to protect children from potential abuse.

Accusers and their attorneys aren’t convinced, and they worry that some priests are being publicly exonerated and put back into contact with children without a thorough and impartial investigation into abuse claims.

They point out that in some cases a priest was returned to ministry, even though his accuser wasn't interviewed as part of an investigation.

The most recent reinstatement of a priest was in July, when Bishop Michael W. Fisher restored the faculties of the Rev. Raymond A. Donohue, who was accused in a Child Victims Act lawsuit and a confidential bankruptcy claim. Donohue denied the allegation.

The diocese said the plaintiff's attorney refused to allow an investigator to interview his client.

Steve Boyd, the plaintiff's attorney, described the board as a “public relations wing of the diocese” that was created to “try and find ways to put priests back into ministry.”

“With regard to the transparency of this group, there just needs to be more,” Boyd said in an August court hearing. “Right now, it is a secret committee that does secret work, and we find out their findings later, without knowing anything about what their process is.”

A diocese spokesman declined to comment for this story about the review board's investigations and the bishop's decisions.

Dioceses across the country have put in place review boards to help bishops handle child sex abuse allegations.

But a national expert on child abuse prevention said the boards are not fully independent and often don’t get all the information they need to analyze cases of alleged abuse.

“The review boards are just another bureaucratic layer in my book,” said Marci Hamilton, founder and chief executive officer of Child USA, a nonprofit think tank organization based in Philadelphia. “Whereas what we really need is an in-depth investigation with all of the facts gathered. That’s really all the survivors are asking for. They really want the truth to come out.”

If law enforcement won’t investigate because criminal statutes of limitation have expired, dioceses might consider turning to an external review by independent experts who have no connection to the church, Hamilton said.


The Rev. Norbert F. Orsolits.
Buffalo Diocese's 1995 Priests' Pictorial Directory

Scandal erupted in 2018


The diocese has faced intense scrutiny over its handling of abuse allegations since a retired priest, the Rev. Norbert Orsolits, admitted to The News in 2018 that he had molested probably dozens of boys earlier in his priesthood.

The admissions prompted a snowball of complaints against priests, a program to compensate victims, state and federal investigations into the diocese, and hundreds of civil lawsuits.

The diocese responded in 2018 by hiring a former FBI agent to examine abuse complaints. A group of lay people pushing for reforms also recommended in 2019 that the diocese make its review board a more independent body and hire additional sex abuse investigators.

In a dozen cases since 2018 where an allegation against a priest was substantiated, the diocese took steps to permanently remove the priest from ministry.

The diocese in most instances has given no explanations about how or why the review board arrives at its conclusions, nor has it made public details of investigations into allegations.

The News did obtain a copy of an investigator's report into accusations of abuse against the Rev. Roy Herberger that deemed the allegations "completely false" and cited a litany of inconsistencies in the accuser's version of events. Attorney Scott F. Riordan, a former prosecutor, spent six months investigating the case. Herberger ultimately was restored to full ministry and sued the accuser for defamation.

The Rev. Roy Herberger on Jan. 22, 2020, sued a man who had accused him of sexually abusing him as a child in a Child Victims Act case. Herberger says he did not abuse the man and sued him for defamation. Derek Gee/News file photo


Several other priests who were permanently removed from ministry due to allegations the diocese says were substantiated through an investigation maintain their innocence and claim they were falsely accused.

The diocese has publicly identified 85 priests since 1950 who had substantiated abuse claims, and another 23 priests who were part of religious orders and served in the diocese at some point since 1950. A 2021 News analysis of CVA lawsuits found that 230 priests who served in the Buffalo diocese were accused of abuse.

The diocese has a contract with multiple lawyers to do the investigative work, the results of which are forwarded to the review board, a group that currently includes a retired state Appellate Court judge, a retired M&T Bank vice president, a licensed clinical social worker and a pediatrician, among others, all of whom are Catholic. The review board makes a written recommendation to Fisher, who ultimately decides whether to reinstate a priest.

The diocese has pledged to investigate all abuse allegations as part of efforts to comply with the New York State Attorney General’s Office, which sued the diocese in 2020 over its handling of accused priests. Investigators attempt to interview any accuser who makes a credible claim against a priest, diocese officials have said.

Accusers in some cases have spoken with the diocese’s investigator, but several have refused, often out of mistrust of the diocese and fear lawyers will try to use the statements against them later.


The Rev. John J. Sardina.
Buffalo Diocese's 1995 Priests' Pictorial Directory

Diocese wanted to ID accuser


At least four priests were cleared of an abuse allegation by the review board and bishop only to face a second allegation after their suspensions were lifted.

One of those priests, the Rev. John Sardina, 90, was suspended from ministry in 2018 and returned in 2019 upon an investigation determining the claims were not substantiated.

The diocese is now investigating a second allegation involving Sardina, and its lawyers asked for a court order to help their inquiry, which Chief Judge Carl L. Bucki recently denied.

Lawyers for the diocese wanted Bucki to allow the release of the name of a woman who accused Sardina of abusing her as a child 50 years ago.

The woman, 61, filed a Child Victims Act lawsuit in State Supreme Court in 2019 and made a claim in the diocese’s federal bankruptcy case. In both instances, she used a pseudonym, LG36. State Supreme Court and federal bankruptcy court typically require public disclosure of interested parties, but both courts have allowed for modifications given the sensitivity of information about abuse victims.

The woman alleged in the lawsuit that Sardina sexually assaulted her after she participated in the sacrament of confession with the priest. The abuses are alleged to have happened from 1969 to 1971 when Sardina was assigned to Coronation of the Blessed Virgin Mary Church in Buffalo.

Sardina denied sexually abusing a minor in court papers answering the plaintiff’s complaint. He denied abusing any children in a 2019 interview with WIVB-TV, as well, although he said he had consensual sex with women and church officials sent him to counseling for that years ago.

The diocese’s lawyers said they reached out to the woman’s attorney for permission to tell Sardina her name so that they could properly investigate the claims. Receiving no response, the diocese filed a motion with Bucki to force the issue.

A lawyer for the diocese told Bucki that the diocese was stuck between a rock and a hard place as it tries to adhere to a sound process for investigating a claim.

“This is solely about the protection of children and determining whether priests are fit for ministry in any form,” said Sara C. Temes, the diocese attorney. “Their hands are completely tied when they can’t even tell the clergy member the name of the accused.”




Archdiocese ordered to halt payments to priests accused of child sex abuse


A U.S. bankruptcy judge rejected the Catholic church's argument that it should

be allowed to keep paying monthly stipends to staff accused of sexual abuse.


Gosh! Shouldn't paedophile priests be allowed to retire in comfort while their victims struggle through their lives?

Author: By David Hammer / Eyewitness Investigator / 4WWL
Published: 4:29 PM CDT September 8, 2022



NEW ORLEANS — A federal bankruptcy judge has ordered the Archdiocese of New Orleans to stop paying retirement benefits to five priests who have been accused of sexually abusing minors or vulnerable adults but are not included on a list of more than 70 clergy the local church considers “credibly accused.”

U.S. Bankruptcy Judge Meredith Grabill issued the order Aug. 31, rejecting the local Catholic church’s argument that it should be allowed to keep paying monthly stipends to priests, deacons and lay staff who face claims of sexual abuse in sealed documents that were turned over to the court by the Archdiocese earlier this year.

From the very beginning of its bankruptcy case in May 2020, the Archdiocese tried to argue that it needed protection from dozens of pending sexual abuse lawsuits, but it should be allowed to keep paying retirement benefits to all living clergy – including those on the “credibly accused list” released by Archbishop Gregory Aymond in November 2018 and updated with additional names over the years since.

Grabill quickly ruled in 2020 that living clergy on the Archdiocese’s official list should not continue to get stipends known as “maintenance” payments, although medical coverage could continue. But she has now taken what she called an “extraordinary” step to amend that ruling based on evidence provided by the Archdiocese this year.

In February 2022, Grabill ordered the church to produce additional internal records from the past 10 years, “including, but not limited to, personnel files, Archdiocesan Review Board … findings, and law enforcement referrals, maintained by any and all departments and offices within the Archdiocese — related to all Archdiocesan priests or lay persons serving in ministerial roles that have been accused of sexual abuse, whether placed by the Archbishop on the Credibly Accused List or not and whether named in a proof of claim filed in this case or not.”

Those records were filed with the court under seal. But when attorneys representing sexual abuse victims saw those records, they argued they “substantiate credible accusations of sexual abuse committed by five priests” who were never included by Aymond on the credibly accused list and, therefore, continued to receive full retirement benefits.

Grabill says those payments must now stop, essentially finding that those priests must wait in line for their claims to be paid just like the abuse victims and other church creditors.

“We continue to evaluate the court’s decision in this matter but currently have no other comment,” the Archdiocese said in a statement.

The five priests whose retirement stipends must end are not named. WWL-TV and The Times-Picayune | New Orleans Advocate teamed up on investigations in 2020 and 2021 that exposed claims against living priests and clergy who were not on the credibly accused list. Aymond added a few names to that list, but others featured in the news reports were never added.

Those include Metairie deacon VM Wheeler, who was criminally charged in December with molesting a preteen boy in the early 2000s, and the Rev. Luis Fernandez, who is retired in South Florida and declined to answer WWL-TV’s questions about one of his former high school students accusing him of molesting him in the 1970s.

The church tried to argue that its responsibility to take care of retired priests and deacons is not governed by U.S. federal law but by the Catholic Church’s own laws, known as canon law. It argued that clergy would only lose their retirement benefits if they were laicized -- or stripped of their ordination as priests or deacons. Aymond told WWL-TV that he could remove priests and deacons from ministry, but he couldn’t forcibly laicize those who don’t voluntarily agree to leave the priesthood or deaconate.  That could only be done by the Vatican.

Grabill rejected the Archdiocese’s argument that she was overstepping her authority.




Burnaby RCMP open sexual assault investigation into

notorious Christian Brother


Edward English moved from N.L. to B.C. after abusing boys at St. John's orphanage


Ryan Cooke · 
CBC News · 
Posted: Sep 22, 2022 6:00 AM NT 


Edward English confessed to police in St. John's in 1975 about abusing boys at Mount Cashel Orphanage. It was covered up by justice officials, and English was allowed to leave the province. He's now accused of the same acts in British Columbia in 1981. (CBC)

Edward English — a Christian Brothers teacher who was sentenced to 10 years in prison for beating and sexually assaulting boys at the Mount Cashel orphanage in St. John's — is the subject of a new police investigation in British Columbia.

Burnaby RCMP have confirmed a complaint was lodged on Aug. 25, and relates to allegations of abuse at a Catholic private school between 1978 and 1982.

While the force would not identify the subject of the investigation, a source with knowledge of the complaint confirmed English, now 74, is the teacher in question.

"I have no idea what you are talking about," English said when contacted by a CBC reporter on Wednesday. "I'm not going to comment on something if I don't know anything about it."

The reporter offered to walk him through the allegations, but he declined, saying "no comment," before hanging up.

A source identified the complainant as a man who is part of a proposed class-action lawsuit in British Columbia. The lawsuit alleges a pair of Catholic private schools and the Roman Catholic Archdiocese of Vancouver allowed six known child abusers to move from St. John's to the Vancouver area, where they continued preying on children.

In a sworn affidavit in the proposed class-action lawsuit, the man — known only as John A. Doe — said English repeatedly molested him during his time as a student at St. Thomas More Collegiate, a Grade 8-12 school in Burnaby, just outside Vancouver.

"The abuse I suffered as a boy has had a profound effect on my faith, my health, and my personal relationships," the man wrote. "I have told my immediate family about it but I have not shared it with others who are close to me, my employer or my work colleagues. I have not reached and may never reach the point where I am prepared to share my identity with the general public."

The allegations set forth in his affidavit have yet to be tested in court.

English moved as part of infamous coverup


Edward English became a household name in Newfoundland and Labrador in 1989, when news broke about what had really been happening at the Mount Cashel Orphanage for decades.

A judicial inquiry revealed that two boys accused English of abusing them in 1975, and that English had even confessed to the Royal Newfoundland Constabulary.

The biggest bombshell of the inquiry, however, was that a deal had been struck between the Christian Brothers organization, the police and the Newfoundland and Labrador Justice Department. English and five other brothers accused of abusing children were quietly moved out of the province around 1975, and no charges were laid.

In 2021, the Archdiocese of St. John's was found liable for decades of abuse at Mount Cashel, pictured here in 1996, and had to declare bankruptcy and sell churches as a result. (CBC)


The Christian Brothers also owned a K-12 school, Vancouver College and St. Thomas More Collegiate. All six brothers landed at those two schools.

By the time the revelations came to light, English and the others had been teaching in British Columbia for more than a decade.

John A. Doe now wants to know how that was allowed to happen.

"I seek accountability for the harm that was done to me by Brother English," he wrote. "Specifically, I want to know how it is that he was allowed to teach at St. Thomas More after having admitted to sexually abusing boys at Mount Cashel."

English investigated in B.C. before


Criminal charges were laid in Newfoundland and Labrador after the Hughes Inquiry. All six of the brothers moved to B.C. were eventually convicted on varying charges of abuse.

But none were ever charged with crimes stemming from their time in B.C., despite allegations now coming to light that their abusive behaviours continued after the coverup was finalized.

A spokesperson for the RCMP in Burnaby confirmed this isn't their first investigation into English. Cpl. Alexa Hodgins said the force conducted an investigation in 2000, related to allegations of a teacher abusing children at St. Thomas More between 1978 and 1982. Hodgins said the file "concluded in early 2001, without charges at the request of the victim."

The complainant was not John A. Doe, but Hodgins said the subject of both investigations was the same person, meaning it had to be Edward English.

For his part, Doe's affidavit states he went to the Burnaby RCMP a few years after leaving St. Thomas More Collegiate, but wasn't aware of any action taken by police after he gave his statement. According to Hodgins, there was no record of a complaint prior to 2000.

English remained in N.B. after prison term


Of all the convictions stemming from Mount Cashel, English received the stiffest punishment.

He was found guilty on 15 counts of physical and sexual abuse and initially sentenced to 13 years in prison. That was later reduced on appeal to 10 years. He was released after serving 5½ years behind bars and granted full parole.

He was released to a halfway house in New Brunswick, and public records show he's remained in the Moncton area ever since, most recently living in a small home on a country road south of Moncton.

According to documents obtained by CBC News, English filed for bankruptcy in 2020. The proceedings were finalized in January 2021, one month before he was named in the proposed class-action lawsuit in Vancouver.

The bankruptcy records show he operated a company called T. English Enterprises. There's little information on the company in Canadian records searches, but according to U.S. customs records, a company called Ted English Enterprises with a Moncton address was responsible for importing religious ornaments from China.

English has been attending proceedings in the proposed class action by video conference from his home in New Brunswick.

Certification hearings were stalled in August as all parties grappled with admissibility of new evidence. Hearings are expected to wrap up in November, and the judge will rule on whether the case proceeds as a class action or as a series of individual lawsuits.